Self-insured Pension Planning by Theatrestudies

Cherokee Digital Services ™.2019. ‘Ultimate Resume’. Apply directly in respect of self-insured pension plan as Trustee. Membership: services available for qualifying individuals and their dependents.



Cherokee Digital: Financial planning and self-insurable* pension planning.

*With or without index-linked security.

The normal practice in the UK is that death-in-service lump sum benefits will be provided on a fully insured basis. This is the case even for schemes which are sufficiently large to have moved away from insurance contracts as the basis for providing pension benefits. Yet there are circumstances when the trustees of the scheme can profitably consider providing the lump sum life cover benefit on a selfinsured basis.

John Cowell senior consultant and actuary at employee benefit consultants William M Mercer explains that there are four main factors that come into play when considering whether the death-in-service lump sum should be insured or selfinsured:

1. Claims variability: The greater the number of active members, the smaller the likely variability in the scheme’s claims experience over time. The smaller the variability, the greater the predictability of the cost. The greater the predictability of the cost, the easier it is to fund the cost of lump sum death benefits from the pension fund. 2. What about variability? What are the factors that occasion greater variability? Variability is also affected by unusual differences in the profile of the active members - for example it will be harder to predict confidently a scheme’s future claims experience if it has many young, lower paid, employees and just a few older very high paid members. a/In such a case, the use of ‘stop loss’ insurance might be advisable so that the larger number of younger employees would be self-insured and the older members would be insured. b/Alternatively all could be self-insured up to a stated amount, and in the case of the death of a higher paid member, the excess over of the stated amount would be insured. For those who want to know more An actuarial analysis of the expected claims outcome and associated variability is often undertaken so that a conclusion can be reached.

Does the pension or benefit depend on how much the contribution is? Strength of scheme funding: If a scheme is strongly funded, the trustees are more likely to be happier to self-insure.

If the funding level is weak, the trustees are more likely to prefer to insure the deathin-service benefit.

Attitude to risk: Catastrophic events do occur. A large number of employees could be killed at the same time. Even in a large scheme the cash flow implications could be severe, perhaps requiring the liquidation of pension assets at a bad time in the market. What steps can Trustees take to mitigate risk? Trustees who have a high aversion to risk are more likely to prefer to keep death benefits fully insured or to buy in some form of supplementary stop loss cover. Availability of good life rates: a comparison of a scheme’s probable future claims experience compared to the cost of the premiums payable on the market might well indicate that it is likely to be cheaper to insure.

Summary Taking into account these four factors, in particular assuming a scheme which has a uniform distribution risk profile among its active members, is there a minimum number of active members that a scheme must have before self-insurance is a practicable option? ‘ Yes,’ answers Cowell, ‘ with the option of stop loss cover, I would say that a scheme must have at least around 1,000 lives’.

Cowell points out there is two-way traffic between the insured and fully self-insured bases with stop loss cover acting as a half-way house. He gives an example: ‘the combined effects of lower interest rates, the minimum funding requirement (MFR) and the loss of the tax credit on UK company dividends are likely to persuade the trustees of some schemes to move back from self-insurance to an insured basis.’ Company acquisitions and disposals with resulting bulk transfers of active members can also radically change the risk profile of a scheme leading to a reassessment of the best way to provide death-in-service benefits. As regards the current availability of good life rates, Cowell remarks: ‘there are at the moment some extremely low rates on offer from insurers - particularly for large schemes’.

Cherokee Digital Services â&#x201E;˘.2019. â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Ultimate Resumeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;. Apply directly in respect of self-insured pension plan as Trustee. Membership: services available for qualifying individuals and their dependents.

The trustees or employer should therefore seek help to research the market to ensure they get the best deal. Mike Mills, who is responsible for the risk broking teams at Mercer, urges trustees or employers who have insured schemes not simply to assume that the insurer providing the pension benefit should also automatically be selected to provide the life cover element.

‘In many cases a better rate can be obtained by going to another insurer who specialises in death-in-service cover’ says Mills and adds ‘there is usually no penalty imposed by the main benefit insurer if the scheme trustees go to another for the group term assurance cover’.

In general for any scheme which insures lump sum death benefits Mills recommends a comprehensive broking exercise to identify the most competitive provider from among the 15 or so players in the UK group life field. i/‘Group term assurance rates are very competitive’, says Mills, ii/‘The insurer quoting the best rates today won’t necessarily remain the most competitive’. He adds: iii/‘Most insurers will guarantee their rates for a two year period so re-broking exercises usually take place on a two year cycle’.

The rates offered to any trustees or employer will depend mainly on previous claims experience and the profile of the employees to be covered. Mills explains: a/‘Insurers are careful about their claims experience and mortality rates differ markedly between different groups of employees. b/’Insurers are competitive but they are still very careful about the nature of the liability they might be taking on’. c/‘It is a free and easy market for scheme trustees to move from insurer to insurer. d/’An insurer will normally take over the risk on the same general terms as the previous insurer other than premium levels.

‘Last Mile’ Cover is available (subject to policy conditions and terms) on application by qualifying individuals on behalf of dependents or family. ‘Ultimate Resume’ is the last CV you’ll ever need send to qualify for what you need for Managed Legacy approval*. *[Subject to insurer terms and policy conditions]

simplifying IT

IT STAFFING SOLUTIONS More and more hard-pressed councils are turning to innovative finance to transform their business model. Public services face increasing cuts. Arts & Culture funding faces battles of its own.

consulting billing staffing CRM

Cherokee Digital As infrastructure risk advisors we are familiar with the requirenments of data analysis, along with the benefits of data insight that can be pooled and shared across the organisation.

For insurers Our Data @ Terminal information management connects directly with brokers’ desks at London Market – Lloyd’s of London and re-insurers.

SaaS on a monthly basis: EC3 and CH. (Zurich)

• Innovation & Recruitment form the backbone of services for Office of The 3rd Sector. • 3 Sector Support is avaiable pcm: ‘as a subscription’. rd

tec hnology consulting

• Available with Microsoft Office 365 and Exchange. • Book-keeping and IT available as subscription option. • Fully insured. Limited liability. SIPP managed pension. pensions.

technology Agency for Office of the 3rd Sector + 44 77 56 44 10 37 ph + 44 117 9558144 fax www.kitky.co.uk

consulting

IT solutions that work for your business. AGENT FOR OFFICE OF THE 3 RD SECTOR.

CRM Service as a subscription. Platform as a Service

CUSTOM SOLUTIONS

Customised software service

With turnkey ‘fair pay’ contracts and services of

ADR available by subscription, grievances are At Cherokee Digital we believe in putting the client firmly in control. With employee-owned providers of

rare, and disputes settled with fully insured cover by Cicero ADR. Choose pay-as-you-go legal

public service ranging from housing delivery to care providers our IT support is available as a ‘turnkey’

IT SUPPORT SOLUTIONS

service. Call centre management as standard, value guaranteed.

expenses’ cover or subscribe to General Counsel services, Apply to us directly.

• SERVER MAINTENANCE & CLOUD.

WEB SOLUTIONS • INTEGRATE WITH OFFICE 365. • SHARE DOCUMENT X-CHANGE. • CONNECT DIRECTLY WITH

flexible solutions for risk management: via CRM

Employee-owned companies achieve significantly higher rates of retention and reduce staff turnover.

EBUSINESS SOLUTIONS The effective organisation displays its design

BROKERS. • GENITUS, TE VERO, ERAT.

APPLICATION MANAGEMENT

ENTERPRISE MANAGEMENT

through its daily operation. This ‘show and tell’

Case workers have access to latest desktop

Communication takes three. One to record,

approach forms the basis of insurer validation,

tools for information management in a context

and another to disseminate, and a third: to

whether in a hospital, operating theatre, school or

fully

observe. As Agent for Office of The 3rd Sector

public-facing front-line service.

GDPR-compliant

with

regulatory

requirement.

we observe change as it occurs and report to

Health and housing provide two areas in which

decision-makers in order that resources can

synergies can be achieved, without unneccesary

be managed, safely, securely, and to best

duplication of service by means of ‘turnkey’

effect.

application management and call handling.

That’s why public service leaders turn to us for

response to each case.

information management.

WE’VE WORKED WITH A DIVERSE CU STOMER BASE. Is your data analysis ‘people ready’? At Cherokee Digital we are part of the Apache Open Software Project. Open Data means insights can be shared instantly.