forest city INFILL the story of a cleveland neighborhood and its conceptual path of renewal
kammeron hughes mla capstone 2013
forest city INFILL
2
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
thank you First I must thank my classmates. These three years have been an absolute joy and I feel so lucky to have been a part of our class. Discovering my passion one piece of trace at a time with you all around me was truly one of the best experiences of my life thus far. I will miss you all (and the bone zone) with all my heart, and cannot wait to see each and everyone one of us achieve success. To my capstone committee and studio professors, Matthew Tucker, Vince deBritto, Jamuna Golden and Rebecca Krinke, who put up with my lack of updates and desire to work completely in my own head, I thank you. You each found a way to drive me and push me in a direction, to explore new parts of this complicated thing that is capstone, and without you I may not have gotten to a point I could call a project. Thank you. To my parents, Paulette and Bill, thank you for all of your support. Because of you I am unafraid to follow my dreams and feel supported 100% of the time. You have encouraged me to go in
my own direction and have always been there to help. Thank you especially for moving to Cleveland, as without that move, landscape architecture may never have been on my life path. I love you.
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
the story of a cleveland neighborhood and its conceptual path of renewal
To my brother Chris, of course your few suggestions were genius. Keep on lawyering. I love you. To my friends, near and far, you keep me sane. I love you. To Cleveland, thank you for being you. kammeron hughes 2013 Master of Landscape Architecture Capstone University of Minnesota
:
How can forest as infill create social, economic and environmental opportunities in a debilitated neighborhood of Cleveland, Ohio?
3
forest city INFILL
4
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
contents
contents
3. p. 52
BACKGROUND
p. 68 pp. 6 - 7
pp. 8 - 9
pp. 10 - 13
pp. 14 - 18
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
A Overview
pp. 56 - 65
B 2015-2035
pp. 66 - 67
C Public
A
B Project
pp. 68 - 71
A Overview
pp. 72 - 81
B 2015-2035
pp. 82 - 83
C Public
pp. 84 - 87
A Overview
pp. 88 - 97
B 2015-2035
pp. 98 - 99
C Public
pp. 100-103
A Overview
Statement
C Reasoning DNeighborhood Selection
& site time line
harvests
space detail
E Kinsman
pp. 22 - 23
F
pp. 24 - 25
G Research
pp. 26 - 31
H Process
Questions
and Ideation
AForest
pp. 38 - 39
BDiagrams C Forest Types
and
Infill
DConceptual
Landuse Planning
pp. 50 - 51
E Detail
ORCHARD ESPLANADE
As Infill
Resources
Designs
harvests
space detail
& site time line
harvests
space detail
6. p. 100
pp. 42 - 49
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
Assets
pp. 32 - 37
& site time line
5. p. 84
pp. 19 - 21
pp. 40 - 41
KINSMAN FIELD
Definitions
2. p. 32
pp. 52 - 55
4.
contents 1. p. 6
CHURCH YARD
7. p. 104
NEXT STEPS
& site time line
5
forest city INFILL
6
kammeron hughes
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
7
Important definitions that will inform the way language is used in design definitions
foreclosure - a bank or other secured creditor selling or repossessing a parcel of real property (immovable property) after the owner has failed to comply with an agreement between the lender and borrower called a “mortgage” or “deed of trust.” abandonment – something abandoned by its owner with the intention of not retaking it community - a social unit larger than a small village that shares common values human interaction scale – the level of community at which people have day to day and human to human contact, interactions landscape scale – the landscape that combines both the lands physical origins and the cultural overlay of human presence
BACKGROUND
economic scale – the level of community at which money is passed and humans make a livelihood
implied edge - a dividing line or border not physically noticeable to the human eye
nature - living things and the outdoors, separate of creations by man
urban fringe - the transition zone where densely urban and suburban areas meet
urban tissue - the built and natural environment that makes up a metropolitan area
sprawl - haphazard growth or extension outward by a population
excess open space – landscape parcels with no program and no necessary need at this moment in time in a certain neighborhood
unbounded city - a city without hard borders such as a river or lake. a city with the ability to grow in at least one direction without physical implications
strategic land amendment - assembled contiguous lots in order to make larger parcels of develop-able land or green space available amenity - something that contributes to physical or material comfort, past those of basic necessities
shrinking city - a city that has lost or is losing large amounts of population and therefore is also suffering from a shrunken built environment - the circumstances or conditions that surround one
need - something required to have a basic quality of life
built environment - built structures that make up how a place looks and feels
edge - a dividing line or border, often uncomfortable with physical differences apparent
natural environment - non built structures that make up the way a place looks and feels
BACKGROUND
infill - the introduction of new land uses asset - anything tangible or intangible that is capable of being owned or controlled to produce economic, environmental or social value forest - an area with a high density of trees or other usable resources resource - a source or supply from which benefit is produced conceptual landuse - an abstract and new way of thinking about landuse plan - how something is applied to the physical landscape
8
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
9
Vacancies, abandonment, vandalism and a changing economic climate have created large areas of low grade urban tissue. project summary
Since the 1960’s declining populations have rattled communities across the rust-belt. Entire community structures are changed by the shrinking of populations and changing of economic climates. Within shrinking communities, homes, and in extreme cases, entire blocks, can become abandoned. Abandonment of homes leads to a multitude of problems; fewer “eyes on the street,� built structures falling apart, dangerous untamed natural areas, community disconnection, fewer tax payers to support public works, schools and other amenities, and expensive infrastructure traveling out to areas that are no longer in need. To limit the danger of decrepit buildings being left to rot, and possibly pose danger for people still residing in the neighborhoods affected, cities are spending billions of dollars to tear down foreclosed and abandoned homes. What is left are communities with an excess of open space and declining
BACKGROUND
opportunities for human interaction. This excess of open space that is created is my capstone canvas. I am exploring how uniting the built and natural environments can improve the sense of community and reduce edge effects on the southeast side of Cleveland, Ohio, USA. This site has been dramatically cleared because of abandonment after shrinking populations and is in need of a renewed sense of place and a sense of community on multiple scales. The site will be reconnected through design to an intact community via human interaction scale, landscape scale, and economic scale.
forest city INFILL
10
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
reasoning
11
reasoning
Ohio Percentage population change, 2000-2010 Gain 10%-19.9% Gain 20% or more No change to 9.9% gain Loss up to 9.9%
reasoning
Cuyahoga County
The catastrophic changes that affected many cities across the US in the 1950’s created a rustbelt consisting of areas appearing war-torn and forgotten. First they were cleared of people by highways and suburban sprawl, then by the disappearance of the built environment and the disintegration of community structure. As these areas lost population, the neighborhoods became abandoned. Over time, vacant buildings were seized by the city, heavily dilapidated structures were demolished and clearance by way of vandalism created a landscape fragmented by a network of open spaces and few single family homes per block.
Percentage population change, 2000-2010 Gain 20% or more Gain 10%-19.9% No change to 9.9% gain Loss up to 9.9% Loss 10% or more
Cleveland
Population change and ranking among the nations largest cities
BACKGROUND
In cities like Cleveland, entire neighborhoods were isolated, seeming worlds away from any economic activity. The unboundedness of Northeast Ohio allowed for an
BACKGROUND
erasure of any context needed to create a sense of place. This change in the late 20th century was followed by the foreclosure crisis starting in 2006. This created another wave of population and housing stock loss on top of already struggling communities. Neighborhoods that had been struggling for years were piled on with new disaster. Low density standalone housing that has made up the built environment of these areas for decades is the most vulnerable to weathering and vandalism. With multitudes of vacant properties on the cities hands, Cleveland and Cuyahoga County created an aggressive demolition policy in hopes of re imagining said communities. This removal of nuisance properties through demolition was done in hopes of
forest city INFILL
12
kammeron hughes
kammeron hughes
reasoning
forest city INFILL
13
reasoning foreclosures removed from landscape
The city of Cleveland has seen a changing urban fabric over the years and exists now in a piecemeal fashion with over 20,000 vacant parcels poking holes in a once connected and vibrant landscape.
foreclosures in 2011
reasoning cont.
increasing public safety, appearance and property values in neighborhoods and clearing the path for new development. While studying these cleared areas from aerial view, it appears an idealized “American Dream� of the pastoral landscape could begin to exist four miles away from a bustling city center, and less than a mile away from important cultural and health institutions. Instead, what exists, are dangerous bare neighborhoods with edge conditions built up by some of the highest economic impactors in Ohio. Very little social and fiscal support is passed over or through these edges into the neighborhoods that could be feeding right into the system. Census tract boundaries disappear as dozens of square miles of residential and industrial space waste away into the landscape. Cuyahoga County Land Bank policies
BACKGROUND
have begun to support positive change as they lay a groundwork where it is possible to make changes at a community level through vacant lot reuse, merging parcels, and supporting urban gardening and small scale agriculture. This policy support is just the very beginning of what needs to happen in these areas for real change and improvement to occur. The reasons that these areas became developed in the first place are still the reasons they deserve a second chance at success now. Proximity to the downtown core, multiple opportunities for public transit and proximity to businesses of high economic and cultural importance exist now. The problems lie in the connections between these things and the neighborhoods themselves. Physical, social, psychological and economic connections are nonexistent.
Valuable open space and a kind of blank canvas characterize the physical environment. Crime, poverty, and a lack of support characterize the social environment.
cleveland foreclosures
Altering the urban fabric is often quite difficult as many public and private hands are in the mix of policy and ownership.
2012
1953
E 75th to E 79th between the red and blue RTA lines
E 75th to E 79th between the red and blue RTA lines
BACKGROUND
As cities like Cleveland go through this decline, however, the urban spaces become more and more flexible. This new found flexibility and the remaining positive possibilities are what create the opportunity for landscape architecture intervention.
14
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
15
neighborhood
Fairfax and Kinsman are two neighborhoods on Cleveland’s near southeast side. neighborhood
Cleveland, Ohio is a city made up of neighborhoods. Over time each neighborhood has garnered an identity of its own.
neighborhood being overlapped by the city’s cultural and medical centers creates multiple dangerous edge conditions.
Fairfax and Kinsman are two neighborhoods on Cleveland’s east side that are ideally located between downtown, the Cuyahoga River, and the museum and university district called University Circle.
After its annexation to Cleveland in 1872, the neighborhoods now known as Fairfax and Kinsman underwent a period of rapid residential development which continued until 1920, when the area’s population reached 60,000. As the city of Cleveland was reaching its highest population in 1950 of over 900,000 people, these neighborhoods acted as the core of the cities industry, and it’s industrial workers. As the industrial needs of the region shrank and families followed the quality highway system outside the city limits, the neighborhood population shrank dramatically. Together today Kinsman and Fairfax have less than 1/5th their pre World War II populations.
Euclid Avenue, near the neighborhood’s northern border, became the site of many of Cleveland’s largest and most architecturally distinguished churches as well as the county’s largest employer, the Cleveland Clinic. The Cleveland Clinic marks the northern edge of the neighborhood and creates an edge in the middle of the census bounded area. The predominantly poverty stricken
BACKGROUND
BACKGROUND
forest city INFILL
16
kammeron hughes
neighborhood
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL neighborhood
Cleveland Clinic and University Hospitals
$11 billion
economic impact in Ohio
The edge conditions on the site create boundaries that block all forms of movement and communication. edge conditions
Railways
30 miles
in Kinsman and Fairfax
Industrial (working and abandoned)
300 acres
in Kinsman and Fairfax
Vacant land
450 acres
BACKGROUND
in Kinsman and Fairfax
17
forest city INFILL
18
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
neighborhood
Vacancies and empty lots create an open network without much structure neighborhood cont.
As these two neighborhoods lost population, they became abandoned. The identity that had been formed over the years is now unintelligible and in some places completely forgotten. The fragmented network that now exists fails to support community, and instead supports further decline and high levels of crime. Street scape on areas that were once part of Cleveland’s most dense retail sector cease to exist as entire blocks consist of boarded up store fronts. The feeling of community appears extremely weak, if not completely lost. The majority of the neighborhoods appear piecemeal at birds eye and street level because of vacant lots and unused infrastructure. As you move south through the neighborhood it becomes highly disconnected because of industrial plants (both in use and abandoned) and multiple rail lines (both freight and rapid
BACKGROUND
19
kinsman
transit). These rail lines pose many problems in the way of pedestrian and vehicle connection, while also creating pockets that are completely cleared of anything but urban shrub fill. They also create multiple opportunities in the Kinsman and Fairfax neighborhoods as in this area three rapid transit stops exist, on two separate lines. This gives the neighborhood an 11 minute train trip from most of its interior into the downtown core as well as out to sprawling suburbs. Pursuits at reuse of vacant sites have been attempted, as a few community garden plots exist in the area to support local residents, but no real job sector through urban agriculture has been created.
Kinsman itself is characterized by wide open spaces and an editable structure. kinsman
Looking at Kinsman as a single entity rather than in the group of foreclosure affected east side neighborhoods tells a more dramatic tale. In the 1960’s the railroads that create boundaries throughout the site and had supported the entire industrial economy started losing work. The people living in Kinsman consisted of mainly blue collar workers, so when the railroads left, and the jobs left, they left as well. While the east side Cleveland neighborhoods are all suffering from vacancy, Kinsman has suffered the most. Entire blocks of homes have been removed at more than one location and the population and housing stock are still declining. The Cuyahoga Land Bank estimates that they will gain another 50 and possibly knock down another 20 vacant buildings in 2013. Kinsman then, is a community
BACKGROUND
disconnected from the formal economy, social network and a city structure that allows a place to thrive. The infrastructure of the city is aging and wearing, and this is evident throughout the neighborhood. The streets haven’t been repaved in years, the sidewalks are nonexistent, and the storm-water infrastructure is unnecessarily collecting runoff from a decidedly non-urban area. The majority of the landscape is made up of broken concrete and turf grass. The turf grass on some parcels is consistently mowed in the growing season, but other than that there is no preparedness for people to return. That turf grass that is mowed suggests other issues in Kinsman. One, that takes money and effort by the city. Two, while it may look
forest city INFILL
20
kammeron hughes
kinsman
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
21
kinsman
28.5%
of households are currently vacant
2012
5,010
1,700
population
housing units lost since 1980
kinsman
pastoral during some seasons, it adds little environmental support and almost no biodiversity. Three, packed urban fill and turf grass offer very little water permeation, further debilitating the city of Cleveland’s already struggling storm-water and sewer system. The systems are combined throughout the city, and have been mandated by the EPA to reduce their runoff into lake Erie by 4.6 billion gallons by 2035.
$37,400
median house value
1951
22,109
6.25
population
acres per person
All of these aspects have led to very little in community support and a non-existent quality of life in Kinsman. While the population has shrunk dramatically, 5,000 people do still call Kinsman home.
1,156
housing units built before 1939
The majority of the adult residents are women, at 65% of the population. The median age of all residents is 26 years old, with the median age of the male population being 21. 65% of the population has a less than high school level education.
BACKGROUND
$12,517
median household income
BACKGROUND
forest city INFILL
22
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
assets
23
assets
heritage trees
churches
assets
vacant buildings
kinsman assets There are unique neighborhood amenities that have persisted and support glimpses of care and ownership throughout the neighborhood. I call these assets. Faith based organizations within the neighborhood bounds of Kinsman have endured, with multiple churches housed in their original buildings and in abandoned homes still drawing parishioners. Other vacant buildings are left standing and in high enough quality that they could be reused in the near future. Others could easily be removed. High quality trees that have been growing since before the days of the high population numbers still live in a few spots throughout the neighborhood. Urban brush and young weed trees are extensive throughout the neighborhood, but only a few native “heritage trees� still
thrive.
rapid transit stops
The historic population of Kinsman worked at the multiple ironwork factories and foundries that thrived through the proximity of the extensive rail infrastructure throughout the metro area. That rail proximity still exists, but rather than a high population of people, Kinsman benefits from a high percentage of open space. While the rail system used to move metalworks and people, it can now work to re-generate the forest city, with Kinsman acting as the growing heart.
vacant parcels
built structure
parcel map
All of these characteristics paint a picture of extreme opportunity.
miles 1
3/4
1/4
0
.5
1 feet
0 0
BACKGROUND
1/2
1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 .5
1
BACKGROUND
2
3
kilometers
24
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
How can you use community assets to create opportunities for social engagement, economic gain and environmental benefits?
kammeron hughes
additional research questions
forest city INFILL
How can landscape architecture work to renew a sense of community in a place that has been lost? How is that sense of community created? This question is one that has been a motivator for landscape architects for generations. Since the beginning of the profession a main goal has been using the landscape to create spaces people want to inhabit or inhabit in specific ways. Looking at this question from a modern point of view after researching historic planning ideals leads to modern and “new” modes of designing for community development. How can open space in debilitated communities be used to successfully create informal economies and a better quality of life for a neighborhoods inhabitants while also reconnecting said community to an existing formal economy and developed area? As best laid plans from the past go to waste what kind of solutions can be made that will allow communities
BACKGROUND
BACKGROUND
25
to flexibly grow as economic impactors and personal motivators change over time? Solutions on how to strengthen communities and creative ways to reconnect lost places into the common society grid will be necessary until all development is deemed “resilient.” Should implied edges created as political boundaries or census tracts be used at the physical human level? How can edges be broken when the functions on each side exist completely separate of each other? What do communities need? What amenities strengthen a community? If faith based organizations pull people to Kinsman on Sundays, how can they pull people in more often or permanently?
forest city INFILL
26
kammeron hughes
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
the story of forest infill as a solution to vacancy in the shrinking city process & ideation
Answering the research questions begins to tell the story of forest infill as a solution to vacancy in the shrinking city. Exploring historic planning of cities, informal economies, foreclosure and city renovation, and the idea of design after loss of density started to unlock possible conceptual solutions. Historical garden city planning took people out of dense, dirty cities and gave them access to a countryside ideal. When Kinsman was at its most dense some of the negative city aspects of life such as smog, closing out of nature and foul air existed. As people left for greener pastures though the opposite aspects of clean air, land lying idle and a lack of society have overcome.
The pastoral openness and newly
BACKGROUND
flexible zoning/parcelization process in Cleveland suggested doing both small scale interventions and large moves across the neighborhood to amplify the assets and begin to solve the problems. In the first iteration of ideation phase two design ideas emerged. One looked outside the site to bring in resources and connect to the external formal economy. The other worked from the core of vacant land and edited from within keeping resources in the neighborhood.
garden city planning diagram
Howard, Ebenezer, and Frederic J. Osborn. Garden Cities of To-morrow. Cambridge, MA: M.I.T., 1965. Print.
BACKGROUND
27
forest city INFILL
28
kammeron hughes
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
29
Scrap metal and an industrial heritage create new opportunities and an identity for the Kinsman neighborhood and its residents. design scenario 1
process & ideation
sculpture or metal goods
Scenario 1: -Cleveland Institute of Art & Cleveland School of the Arts use existing warehouse buildings for large scale piece manufacturing -Scrap yards surrounding site support material needs of classes -Recycling yard is added to the site to “organize” materials as well as create jobs for the community -Said recycling yard should create power in some way -”Park” area next to site becomes display space for sculpture and improved public green -Bridges into site become neighborhood signifiers by being amended with scrap metal and artistic talent of students working in the area -Storage and collection of scrap metal creates space in interesting ways Both the pedestrian and train traffic experience improved by
BACKGROUND
BACKGROUND
forest city INFILL
30
kammeron hughes
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
31
An urban forest of high quality native species takes over the void left after population loss while creating regional ecosystem benefits. process & ideation
design scenario 2
land’s largest and oldest sewer pipes lay under this site)
Scenario 2: -An urban forest of high quality native plant species is created in the void left from population loss. -This will suggest to the city, and surrounding areas, plants that can be used and left basically untouched, that will resist looking like the scrub plants left in the current landscape. -Create a native seed bank and street tree “grove” for the county. -Infrastructure is consolidated and residential units (11) from the interior are removed, while the adjacent residential area is improved. -Rapid Transit stops become “forest” stops with land bridge atmosphere attributed, to remove the “dark corner” feeling created by entering the site under crumbling bridge structures -Storm-water pipes under site can be day lit in forested areas and improved to be areas of retention and treatment (some of Cleve-
BACKGROUND
BACKGROUND
-Existing buildings (only 4 warehouses) become urban nature education centers and/or a magnet school based around agriculture
32
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
How can you use community assets to create opportunities for social engagement, economic gain and environmental benefits?
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
33
34
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
forest as infill
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
35
forest city INFILL
36
kammeron hughes
kammeron hughes
The systems put into place to create a beneficial landscape in Kinsman range from larger scale stabilization processes to small parcel scale storm-water collection and reuse. Each parcel has a unique set of characteristics and therefore will be edited, accentuated and managed in a unique way.
Forest as infill is a conceptual solution to vacancy in the shrinking city forest infill solutions
Kinsman will be an experiment in solutions to increase quality of place in shrinking cities across the globe. Forest is used as infill and in turn generates economic, environmental and social opportunities. As the residents of Kinsman begin to feel a community connection through the physical growth of high quality forest on their vacant parcels, economic and social activity will increase. Ownership of the land and a unique physical appearance will create community strength literally from the ground up. As Kinsman grows a forest inside its boundaries, it will begin to benefit the greater metro area. Kinsman will be the life generator for the forest city. The edges created by the rails themselves that act as disconnecters become beneficial with the growth of a working forest. They provide large scale movement opportunities while also suggesting a “walled city” affect for the most heavily forested portion of Kinsman. Entrance experiences are heightened by the elevat-
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
ed rail lines and the landscape change from built up streetscapes to working orchard, nursery and forest space. The neighborhood of Kinsman will supply innovation to the region and remove a huge portion of runoff from entering the overrun sewer system in the area. By 2040 over 44,000 trees located in both working and natural plantings will collect over 33 million gallons of storm-water a year, and that doesn’t include all the regional benefits of street trees and native plantings added to urban vacant lots. The forest system has multiple benefits aside from beautifying Cleveland’s streets and generating a more resilient landscape across the region. Education opportunities abound in a working forest. A magnet school based first on the forest maintenance and growth then expanding to include technology and craft ventures will anchor the neighborhood of Kinsman as a highlight of the Cleveland Metropolitan School System.
Twenty seven percent of the parcels in Kinsman are currently vacant. Ten percent of those vacant properties have a vacant building in the boundaries. Most of the vacant parcels are owned by the city of Cleveland through foreclosure and bank purchase or tax delinquency. This creates opportunity for larger scale site editing and greater opportunity for landuse or zoning changes. The design implementation in Kinsman happens on multiple scales. To begin, traditional zoning is conceptualized and changed to include more detailed information about what kinds of zones can become working forest for economic benefit. Once the necessary areas are zoned and given the policy base needed to implement important landscape changes, the landuse plans can be put into place.
forest city INFILL
Design implementation begins in 2015. The critical paths through each design element begin with basic site preparedness steps. Each change, removal or addition to a parcel in Kinsman aims to bring economic, environmental or social benefit to current residents in the neighborhood and surrounding communities. Every vacant parcel in 2015 is treated with similar scaffolding edits. Any non natural materials are collected and inventoried. Lots with turf grass that use city of Cleveland resources by way of mowing, water, sewer or electricity resources will be removed from the cities list of responsibilities and be given to the Kinsman neighborhood.
37
Removal of reusable, compostable or sell-able resources
Removal for sale of reusable, compost-able or sell-able resources
Seeding
Harvest of growing resources
Growth of resources
diagrams
These diagram represent the mine, harvest and removal of resources on each forest infill site
Three new categories of landuse are born in Kinsman. Source, flex and firm. These three landuse categories apply to the working forest specifically but can be edited and molded to fit any economic, social, or environmentally beneficial temporal parcel plan. The working forest infill applied through these three lenses creates a strong scaffolding from which Kinsman can grow.
Removal and reuse of resources in site
Renovation and update of built environment
Ongoing system
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
wood product
nuts
aspen willow switchgrass
walnut pecan ohio buckeye
seeds and cones
built material
heritage trees rain gardens working fields
transplants big toothed aspen tulip tree red maple scarlet oak sassafras apple flowering dogwood serviceberry phytoremediation plants
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
r me su m
stormwater
win
sp r
heritage trees rain gardens working fields
n um
resources The resources harvested throughout Kinsman are its life breath in the new and improved community. Resources vary from the removal of exotic and non-native species and how those are then composted on adjacent sites, to the growing nursery forests that supply transplantable living things to vacant parcels throughout the metro area.
native trees native forbs native shrubs phytoremediation plants bulbs
r te
carbon
au t
metal concrete wood asphalt
turf grass weeds leaf litter fruit waste
39
sycamore tulip tree walnut pecan sassafras
biomass
composting
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
bark
pulp lumber
g in
38
limbs and boughs green ash american elm willow big toothed aspen walnut sycamore
cut flowers
The harvest of resources can last throughout the year and changes over time as each parcel transitions from quick stabilization harvest techniques to high level economic gainers or private land ownership.
flowering dogwood tulip tree peony rose daylily tulip hyacinth
fruit
The diversity of harvested resources not only benefits community members economically, it also begins to create social opportunity spaces and guarantees a high level of biodiversity throughout the Kinsman neighborhood.
apple currant blackberry blueberry raspberry grapes
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
forest city INFILL
40
kammeron hughes
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
41
harvest-able resources & common removals source forest
forest infill types
flex forest
Nursery stock and consistently harvested materials
cut flowers wood products limbs and boughs bark biomass nuts seeds and cones fruit
Harvested and working environment with selective pieces and parts curated for future site use
cut flowers wood products limbs and boughs bark biomass nuts seeds and cones fruit
firm forest
transplants
composting built material
storm-water carbon credit
composting built material
storm-water carbon credit
composting
storm-water carbon credit
Once was a working landscape but has since been deemed private or zoned for non-harvest related activities
nuts seeds and cones fruit
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
transplants
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
forest city INFILL
42
kammeron hughes
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
2 mile long detail slice
assets and forest infill axon
conceptual landuse plan
The detail design slice is made up of unique neighborhood assets, the highest percentage of vacancy in Cleveland and three major public transportation options The major design moves are implemented on a slice of the Kinsman neighborhood within which to apply the forest infill strategies at a more detailed scale.
vacant lots turn to forest infill
The Kinsman slice acts as a way for the neighborhood to change, as well as an experimental section from which other vacancies can be edited and renewed. The slice covers multiple kinds of vacancies and therefore multiple kinds of solutions, and their subsequent phasing.
Kinsman assets
feet 0
1000
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
43
forest city INFILL
44
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
ownership and partnership
ownership and partnership
27 % source 2015
40 % source 2020
church
The Cuyahoga County Land Bank and the city of Cleveland are the current owners of all the gray parcels in the ownership map to the right. Those parcels are the first chosen to receive forest infill. Through this plan the land bank properties are transitioned to a new neighborhood/city development corporation who manages the beginnings of forest infill parcels and takes ownership of street side plantings as well as the original sale of the vacant lots.
45
church
More faith based institutions have taken ownership of vacant parcels on the northern part of the site, while the working industrial companies at the southern tip have worked with the land bank to take over control of the forest infill sites in their vicinity. cmsd
cmsd
The industrial companies are working with residents in the neighborhood to plant, study and harvest phytoremediation resources on their parcels. The Cleveland Municipal School District (CMSD) is partnered with the land bank to control and study large swaths of source forest in the slice.
The churches on the northern edge of the site take ownership of the parcels surrounding their sites to manage as they and the neighborhood see fit.
industrial
public space source forest flex forest firm forest
Kinsman residents have the opportunity to rent or work with any of the source forest infill parcels.
forestry building vacant building planted miles
1
3/4
1/2
1/4
0
.5
1 feet
0
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
forest city INFILL
46
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
ownership and partnership
ownership and partnership
28 % source 12 % flex 2025
church
botanical garden
2030
40 % forest
The Cleveland Municipal school district has taken ownership of additional parcels in 2025 to begin working on an agricultural innovation magnet school on the northern edge of Kinsman. The school district has also partnered with the industrial parcels to increase the research and study of phytoremediation plant resources .
47
church
In 2030 the forest as infill landuse plan has been implemented to a point where private landowners who reside in Kinsman are looking to buy working parcels and use them as a personal asset.
27% source 12% flex 1 % firm 40 % forest
cmsd
cmsd
industrial
industrial
public space source forest flex forest firm forest forestry building vacant building planted
miles
1
3/4
1/2
1/4
0
.5
1 feet
0
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
forest city INFILL
48
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
ownership and partnership
ownership and partnership
27 % source 9 % flex 4 % firm
botanical garden
2035 The Cleveland Botanical Garden and Cleveland Museum of Natural History have started a partnership with the Kinsman land development bank in 2035. These two institutions are interested in research and the greater benefit the Kinsman forest can have on the metro region.
49
botanical garden
2040
church
church
A few of the areas managed by the Cleveland Municipal School District have been transitioned to firm forest, and public space, by 2040. These continue to be looked after by the magnet school students, but no longer act as large economic and research assets.
40 % forest
cmsd
17 % source 16 % flex 8 % firm 41 % forest
cmsd
By 2040, the Kinsman forest has spread to an area larger than the slice itself, and multiple other partnerships have been forged.
The botanical gardens urban agriculture program takes over a large greenhouse and multiple parcels to open up a market and working station for their forest resources and begins to act as a large benefactor for the Kinsman forest.
The neighborhood is now a destination for both visitors to the forested park areas and the market and esplanade, as well as a place the residents of Kinsman can be proud to call home.
industrial
industrial
public space source forest flex forest firm forest forestry building vacant building planted
miles
1
3/4
1/2
1/4
0
.5
1 feet
0
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
forest city INFILL
50
detail sites
pg. 84
kammeron hughes
pg. 68
public space 27 % source
source forest flex forest firm forest forestry building
40 % source
vacant building planted
28 % source 12 % flex 40 % forest
27% source 12% flex 1 % firm 40 % forest
pg. 52
pg. 100
2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
detail sites
51
To understand what Kinsman with forest infill feels like to a human, and also to see what exactly is harvested, what resources are mined from the landscape, we now jump down in scale again to four specific sites that deserve greater exploration.
CHURCH YARD
KINSMAN FIELD
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
27 % source 9 % flex 4 % firm 40 % forest
ORCHARD ESPLANADE
17 % source 16 % flex 8 % firm 41 % forest
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
forest city INFILL
52
kammeron hughes
2855 E 79th Street
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
53
6 minute walk
church yard
CHURCH YARD
KINSMAN FIELD
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
ORCHARD ESPLANADE
feet
0
1000
2000
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
forest city INFILL
54
kammeron hughes
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
now public space
2015
2855 E 79th Street
church yard
The spot that begins the entire transformation of the neighborhood is not a vacant lot, but using the community cornerstone, The New Community Apostolic Church, begins to support any economic benefit possibilities happening on the surrounding vacant lots after quick stabilization of the neighborhood. The church is surrounded by vacant land including an unused parking lot. Said parking lot marks the very first move of forest infill. Sycamore trees are brought in as broken concrete is removed to create a welcoming and usable space for church gathering events and a neighborhood market. The church yard is adjacent to one of the transit stops in Kinsman, and exists right along a major bus route. The church yard is weighted more heavily in the social and economic benefit categories than environmental affects, but the sycamore trees that will carry through the sites
history collect thousands of gallons of storm-water each year and support biodiversity of the neighborhood. As the neighborhood esplanade develops, the church yard itself will transition to a more private space, and the market and community activities it hosts will move to larger open spaces that have been improved over the years through selective harvest. The sycamores planted in 2015 become a ritual and community identifier for people growing up in and visiting the neighborhood. As the surrounding parcels are constantly at change acting as economic, environmental and social benefactors, this lot is the starting anchor that holds a constant.
public space
public space
public space
public space
public space
CHURCH YARD
2020 2025 2030 2035 2040
55
forest city INFILL
56
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
57
flex forest 2855 E 79th Street In 2015 the church yard has had quick stabilization harvesting of concrete and the beginnings of turf grass and exotic removal and composting. Sycamores are planted in formal rows, and will grow to create a formal anchor space for the neighborhood. A local market begins here to host the local farmers and neighborhood residents selling resources they have mined from their parcels or created with their hands.
2015
removal and compost of turf grass
CHURCH YARD
seeding of native meadow groundcover after turf is removed
growth of tree line and harvest of limbs and boughs, bark, seeds and cones
addition of market stalls and renovation of church building
removal and reuse of built materials
sale of transplants from other parcels
CHURCH YARD
seeding and care of grape vines on chain link fence
forest city INFILL
58
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
59
flex forest 2855 E 79th Street In 2020 the church has taken ownership of more surrounding parcels and has started a cut flower and bulb harvesting field to support its events as well as sell at its weekly market.
2020
removal and compost of turf grass
CHURCH YARD
seeding and subsequent harvest of cut flowers and bulbs
growth of tree line and harvest of limbs and boughs, bark, seeds and cones
improvement of market stalls and additional renovation of church building
removal and reuse of built materials
sale of transplants from other parcels harvest of bark from sycamore trees
CHURCH YARD
seeding and care of grape vines on chain link fence
forest city INFILL
60
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
61
flex forest 2855 E 79th Street The cut flower and bulb fields are thriving as the church prepares additional parcels for resource management, The market is thriving and is still a major support for the entire Kinsman neighborhood as it is known throughout the city and attracts both Kinsman residents and outsiders to support the local economy.
2025
removal and compost of exotic species and urban fill
CHURCH YARD
seeding and subsequent harvest of cut flowers and bulbs
growth of tree line and harvest of limbs and boughs, bark, seeds and cones
improvement of market stalls and additional renovation of church building
harvest of bark and seeds from sycamore trees
sale of transplants from other parcels
CHURCH YARD
harvest of grape vines on chain link fence
forest city INFILL
62
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
63
flex forest 2855 E 79th Street The formal sycamore plantings are getting large enough in 2030 to create a more private experience in the church yard, with possibilities to be blocked from the street. As the market is now well known, a major street presence every day is unnecessary to keep it busy, but the plantings do not completely block traffic, therefore inviting guests in to the yard, to experience the site that was first edited in the Kinsman forest.
2030
edit of fencing to accommodate future grape vines
seeding and subsequent harvest of cut flowers and bulbs seeding of grape vines
CHURCH YARD
growth of tree line and harvest of limbs and boughs, bark, seeds and cones
sale of goods from market stalls and church events
harvest of bark and seeds from sycamore trees
sale of transplants from other parcels
CHURCH YARD
harvest of grape vines on chain link fence
forest city INFILL
64
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
65
flex forest 2855 E 79th Street The church is now producing their own grapes along with cut flowers and bulbs. The fall and spring harvests bring many people and the market still acts as an anchor at the southern edge of the Kinsman market esplanade.
2035
harvest of grapes
CHURCH YARD
seeding and subsequent harvest of cut flowers and bulbs
growth of tree line and harvest of limbs and boughs, bark, seeds and cones
harvest of bark and seeds from sycamore trees
harvest of grape vines on chain link fence
sale of goods from market stalls and church events
CHURCH YARD
forest city INFILL
66
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
2855 East 79th Street
Church yard market as anchor church yard
The church yard market is the anchor of Kinsman from the beginning. Acting as the economic heart the market supports the harvest of resources throughout Kinsman and brings people in from other neighborhoods to purchase goods.
environmental benefits social opportunity economic impact
sycamore grove sculpted wall grape vines and orchard cut flower fields church built structure
2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040
CHURCH YARD
67
forest city INFILL
68
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
69
7701 Kinsman Avenue 6 minute walk
Kinsman Field
CHURCH YARD
KINSMAN FIELD
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
ORCHARD ESPLANADE
feet
0
1000
2000
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
forest city INFILL
70
kammeron hughes
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
now 2015 7701 Kinsman Avenue
Kinsman Field
Public space and energy production are the focus at Kinsman Field. Selective harvest and controlled site succession create a working landscape that has a high production and export value and then transitions into high quality open space to support the increased population and activity in Kinsman.
the existing infrastructure through street trees, native plant seeding and improved materiality. public space Once Kinsman has a renewed tree canopy the resources travel out to the greater metro area to improve Cleveland’s forest canopy and natural ecosystems overall. public space
The exports from sites such as this travel various distances. At the beginnings of the infill forest majority of exports leave their specific parcel but move around in the Kinsman neighborhood to improve
public space
public space
public space
KINSMAN FIELD
2020 2025 2030 2035 2040
71
forest city INFILL
72
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
73
source forest 7701 Kinsman Avenue Kinsman Field is a major resource harvester in 2015. The Cleveland Municipal School District has taken management responsibility for the site, after partnering with the Cuyahoga County Land Bank.
2015 2035
The major production on this site is biomass harvest, mainly of switchgrass.
built materials harvested
KINSMAN FIELD
seeding and growth of walnut trees
seeding and growth of biomass grasses
harvest of walnuts
harvest of biomass grasses
heritage tree growth
planting of tulip trees
carbon sequestration storm-water collection
harvest of tulip transplants
KINSMAN FIELD
forest city INFILL
74
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
75
source forest 7701 Kinsman Avenue As biomass harvesting continues, the school district takes advantage of the vacant buildings to the north of the site and take over those parcels as well. The buildings are renovated to become greenhouses so more intensive year round research can take place on site.
2020 2035
The population of Kinsman being young and high school educated suggests that the addition of these agricultural opportunities could greatly affect residents current economic state as well as long term future.
built materials harvested greenhouse built
KINSMAN FIELD
seeding and growth of walnut trees
seeding and growth of biomass grasses
harvest of walnuts
harvest of biomass grasses
heritage tree growth
planting of tulip trees
carbon sequestration storm-water collection
harvest of tulip transplants
KINSMAN FIELD
forest city INFILL
76
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
77
source forest 7701 Kinsman Avenue Biomass production has been moved south in Kinsman to larger less public sites, as Kinsman Field begins to transition into a public open space.
2025 2035
Tulip trees to be harvested at transplants are planted in the switchgrass fields. As these trees grow the switchgrass is shaded out, and production transitions to a nursery and public space area. The walnut harvesting and greenhouse production are still going strong.
greenhouse materials seeded and harvested
seeding and growth of walnut trees
seeding and growth of biomass grasses
harvest of walnuts
harvest of biomass grasses
street removed and groundcover seeded
heritage tree growth
planting of tulip trees
carbon sequestration storm-water collection
harvest of tulip transplants
tulip trees planted tulip tree transplants harvested
KINSMAN FIELD
KINSMAN FIELD
forest city INFILL
78
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
79
flex forest 7701 Kinsman Avenue In 2030 Kinsman Field becomes a flex space, where previously it had been all source forest. Less planting and harvesting of tulip trees exists, and selective stands are left in place to create shade and gathering areas once the field is made completely public.
2030 2035
greenhouse materials seeded and harvested
seeding and growth of walnut trees harvest of walnuts
tulip tree growth
heritage tree growth
tulip tree transplants harvested
carbon sequestration storm-water collection
street removed and groundcover seeded
KINSMAN FIELD
KINSMAN FIELD
harvest of tulip transplants
forest city INFILL
80
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
81
flex forest 7701 Kinsman Avenue Kinsman Field is a transitioned in 2035 into a fully public park. Being at the corner of two busy thoroughfares and now existing in a busy working neighborhood, the public open space acts as a gathering space for large public events, as well as an indicator of the increased quality of life in Kinsman, and how that quality of life came about.
2035
greenhouse materials seeded and harvested
seeding and growth of walnut trees harvest of walnuts
tulip tree growth
heritage tree growth carbon sequestration storm-water collection
street removed and groundcover seeded
KINSMAN FIELD
KINSMAN FIELD
growth of permanent park trees
forest city INFILL
82
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
7701 Kinsman Avenue
Kinsman field opened to public Kinsman Field
Kinsman field is unique in that it has a major biomass harvesting function for the first 15 years of its life, yet slowly lets people in to experience what a working field of switchgrass is like. The grass biomass function changes as tulip tree transplants are added. This render highlights what the experience would be like in the summer of 2025 for a person exploring Kinsman field. The field is a great location for educational outings and for other vacant lots to adopt practices from. From this time in Kinsman Field’s life the public is welcome into the area.
environmental benefits social opportunity economic impact
walnut alley planted field building and greenhouse heritage tree groundcover paths
2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040
KINSMAN FIELD
83
forest city INFILL
84
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
85
7701 Kinsman Avenue 6 minute walk
Kinsman Field
CHURCH YARD
KINSMAN FIELD
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
ORCHARD ESPLANADE
feet
0
1000
2000
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
forest city INFILL
86
kammeron hughes
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
now 2015 7798 Trenton Avenue
Residential
The farthest south site that gets detail treatments is part of the improved residential neighborhood in Kinsman. Fifty year old apartment buildings were removed in 2011 and fenced in vacant land was left. The surrounding streets hold most of the inhabited homes in Kinsman, as well as a new elementary school. The most intensive nursery site is located here, as well as a large ground cover native planting bank.
2020
Harvesting here exists until 2035 when it becomes flex space until residential units are rebuilt and selective tree and resource removals create a “wild� open upland forest for public use.
2025 public space
public space
public space
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
2030 2035 2040
87
forest city INFILL
88
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
source forest 7798 Trenton Avenue The residential forest is a major tree transplant production area. The site is currently all fenced in, which creates a great opportunity for high level production, as the public is originally kept out of the site.
2015
The tree transplants first are transferred around vacant lots in Kinsman, either to begin another working parcel or act as street tree replacements. Once the neighborhood is reforested, the transplants can begin traveling out into the greater metro area.
curb and street removal and reuse
removal of turf grass and exotic species
planting of rain garden plants
seeding of hops vines on fence planting of tulip and scarlet oak trees
tulip trees planted
heritage tree growth
harvest of tulip tree transplants
scarlet oak growth
removal and compost of turf and groundcover
removal and compost of urban fill and groundcover
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
89
forest city INFILL
90
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
source forest 7798 Trenton Avenue The residential forest is still an active nursery in 2020, but the street scape is being transformed in preparation for a more public existence.
2020
Curbs are removed and rain gardens line the edge of the street, while sidewalks are improved.
curb and street removal and reuse
growth and harvest of tulip and oak trees
seeding of hops vines on fence
planting of rain garden plants
harvest of hop flowers
planting of tulip and scarlet oak trees
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
tulip trees planted
heritage tree growth
harvest of tulip tree transplants
scarlet oak growth harvest of scarlet oak trees
removal and compost of turf and groundcover removal of curbs and gutters rain garden seeding
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
91
forest city INFILL
92
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
flex forest 7798 Trenton Avenue While the residential forest is still private, the transition to public park space is in full swing. Selective transplant harvest of tulip and oak trees begins to leave specimens for the future public park.
2025
planting of rain garden plants
growth and harvest of tulip and oak trees
seeding of hops vines on fence
harvest of rain garden plants and seeds
harvest of hop flowers
planting of tulip and scarlet oak trees
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
tulip trees planted
heritage tree growth
sassafras and maple planted
harvest of tulip tree transplants
scarlet oak growth
harvest of sassafras and maple transplants
harvest of scarlet oak trees
rain garden seeding
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
93
forest city INFILL
94
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
95
flex forest 7798 Trenton Avenue Kinsman field is opened to the public in 2030, while transplant harvest of red maple and sassafras trees is still in effect. The groundcover of native meadow throughout most of the site under the trees is used in seed banking, and the fences that lined the entire site are still used in places for hop flower growing and harvest.
2030
harvest of rain garden plants and seeds
growth and harvest of tulip and oak trees
seeding of hops vines on fence
harvest of hop flowers
harvest of tulip and scarlet oak transplants
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
native meadow seeded
heritage tree growth
sassafras and maple planted
growth of permanent trees
scarlet oak growth
harvest of sassafras and maple transplants
harvest of scarlet oak trees
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
curb and gutter removal seeding of rain garden
forest city INFILL
96
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
97
flex forest, almost firm forest 7798 Trenton Avenue In 2035 the residential forest is fully available for public use. Programmed to work in conjunction with the elementary school in Kinsman, the open space is used throughout the year by school children and the wider public.
2035
The edges of the residential forest are being redeveloped with single family homes as land value increases in Kinsman because of the reforestation and innovative entrepreneurial opportunities.
harvest of rain garden plants and seeds
growth of permanent trees
heritage tree growth
harvest of sassafras and maple transplants
scarlet oak growth harvest of scarlet oak trees
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
new housing units built
forest city INFILL
98
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
7798 Trenton Avenue
The residential forest becomes a high quality parkland with diverse tree species residential forest
The residential forest in 2035 has just become public ground, and the parcels surrounding it are being redeveloped to house additional residents of Kinsman. The working forest has become a new park that supports the biodiversity and seed collection aspects of the new Kinsman identity. In 2035 the edges of the park are still being edited, thus considered flex space, while the majority of the interior trees that are left will be home here in the forest for the remainder of their life. The selective harvest on the parcels surrounding the residential forest are planted such that intensely harvested areas are located in future building footprints, and selective trees are left outside those footprints. Thus, the lots will have 20 year old trees in a safe place when additional residential units are built.
environmental benefits social opportunity economic impact
heritage tree and surroundings raingarden and streetscape planted fields hops vines housing development
2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
99
forest city INFILL
100
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
101
2801 East 79th Street 6 minute walk
Orchard Esplanade
CHURCH YARD
KINSMAN FIELD
RESIDENTIAL FOREST
ORCHARD ESPLANADE
feet
0
1000
2000
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
CONCEPTUAL LANDUSE PLAN
forest city INFILL
102
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
103
This aspen planting is 4 rows deep of a 6’ by 6’ grid, then transitions into a source forest for street trees.
Along the esplanade multiple parcels of source forest are made up of aspen biomass plantings. The western edge of E 79th supports tree biomass to create a dense edge on one side, while the eastern edge supports meadow and grass biomass source parcels. The western edge also receives editing in the way of rain garden and sidewalk improvements.
The site just north of the church yard is the heart of the “edible forest” development in Kinsman. The Current conditions on this site include three vacant buildings that hint at the historic density and activity once happening in this neighborhood. Two fenced in parcels will support fruit tree groves with an edible understory of currants, strawberries, and raspberries. The western edge of the esplanade will gain built structures as the economy in Kinsman grows. As a resource place holder biomass plantings take up each future building site. The biomass plantings on the western edge are easily clear cut to put up the built structures, while the eastern edge will have open forest and edible forest parcels to support established trees when the public begins to visit Kinsman more regularly.
ORCHARD ESPLANADE
Moving the northern edge of the esplanade, adjacent to the prairie, we are introduced to the vacant warehouse sites and the second transit stop. The intervention on this site is slight for the first few years as ownership needs to be transitioned to the neighborhood development committee. Once this has taken place, the fenced in site becomes an experiment in storm-water control and collection as well as native tree harvesting possibilities. The innovation and agriculture magnet school begins as a external campus where after school and extra curricular programs are hosted but transitions into a fully formed campus experience on this site by 2040. By 2040 the esplanade has grown to a developed corridor that has a unique identity representing the ways Kinsman was renewed. In 1950 this neighborhood supported the economy with the people it housed, now it supports the greater regional economy, ecology and social network through forestry.
Over time many biomass parcels located on E 79th will transition to built structure.
This aspen biomass planting consists of an entire parcel planted at a dense 5 foot on center grid.
The Orchard Esplanade offers multiple parcels for edible forest and plant growth as well as a public streetscape and built structures for rent to sell local goods and supply Kinsman with much needed services orchard esplanade
The biomass planting acts as a natural barrier for the street tree forest, while still acting as a resource on its own.
2015
2015
now turf grass section
2015
2015
meadow section
The pear grove begins in a fenced in parcel on East 79th. The chain link fence that currently exists is used to trellis grape vines, and keep the public out of the harvest area.
2015 2020
The grove is a piece of source forest, where half the trees are used as transplants and half are used strictly to harvest fruit.
A large group of parcels on the esplanade receive quick stabilization efforts of turf grass removal and replacement of native meadow grasses.
2025 edible source forest esplanade
ORCHARD ESPLANADE
This large parcel group will transition into open public space as the esplanade grows in popularity. As of 2015 its main action is storm-water collection, while seed banking will begin to happen after the native plantings no longer need intensive management.
104
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
105
Kinsman will gain a distinct community identity and a renewed density of place in closing
Forest as infill used as a design solution to vacancy in Kinsman creates economic, social and environmental opportunities that previously did not exist. The young high school educated population will be given opportunities from the start to try something new and use the skills they already posses to build a future career. Working with resource heavy lots with both city employees and researchers will lead to a population with unique
NEXT STEPS
NEXT STEPS
skill sets and an understanding of innovative agricultural practices. An entrepreneurial spirit throughout the whole of Kinsman is garnered as the population matures in a changing environment. Over time, through forest infill, Kinsman will gain a distinct community identity and a renewed density of place that makes it an intriguing and exciting place to spend time.
106
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
references
kammeron hughes
forest city INFILL references
Alberti, M., & Marzluff, J. M. (2004). Ecological resilience in urban ecosystems: linking urban patterns to human and ecological functions. Urban ecosystems, 7(3), 241-265.
“Cleveland Parks 1895 Plan.” Cleveland Parks 1895 Plan. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://www.railsandtrails.com/ Cleveland/1895ClevelandParks/index.htm>.
As neighborhoods empty, planners look for new and bold uses for Cleveland’s green acres | cleveland.com. (n.d.). Blogs cleveland.com. Retrieved October 10, 2012, from http://blog.cleveland.com/metro/2011/03/imagination_could_transform_va.html
“Cleveland Waste-to-Energy Power Plant Could Make Eco History.” Earth911com Cleveland WastetoEnergy Power Plant Could Make Eco History Comments. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://earth911.com/news/2010/02/16/cleveland-waste-to-energy-powerplant-could-make-eco-history/>.
Percentage of Vacant Housing Units in Phoenix, AZ by Zip Code. (n.d.). Zip Code, Area Code, City & State Profiles | ZipAtlas. Retrieved October 10, 2012, from http://zipatlas.com/us/az/phoenix/zip-code-comparison/percentage-vacant-housingunits.htm A Tale of Three Cities - The Detroit Blog - TIME.com. (n.d.). The Detroit Blog - One year. One city. Endless opportunities. - TIME.com. Retrieved October 10, 2012, from http://detroit.blogs.time.com/2010/01/08/a-tale-of-three-cities/ “Browse Items (22 Total).” Garden Valley. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://csudigitalhumanities.org/exhibits/items/ browse/tag/Garden Valley>. “Capitol Canopy | Sacramento Capitol Mall Design Competition Winner | ATLAS Lab « World Landscape Architecture – Landscape Architecture Webzine.” World Landscape Architecture Landscape Architecture Webzine RSS. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://worldlandscapearchitect.com/capitol-canopy-sacramento-capitol-mall-design-competition-winner-atlas-lab/>. Census 2010 Ohio village, city, county populations and demographics | cleveland.com. (n.d.). Cleveland OH Local News, Breaking News, Sports & Weather - cleveland.com. Retrieved November 20, 2012, from http://www.cleveland.com/datacentral/ index.ssf/2011/03/census_2010_ohio_village_city.html “City Council Changes Residential Zoning to Support Urban Agriculture.” Residential Zoning. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://cccfoodpolicy.org/blog/city-council-changes-residential-zoning-support-urban-agriculture>.
“Comprehensive Report Ecological System - Northeastern Interior Dry-Mesic Oak Forest.” Comprehensive Report Ecological System - Northeastern Interior Dry-Mesic Oak Forest. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://www.natureserve.org/explorer/ servlet/NatureServe?searchSystemUid=ELEMENT_GLOBAL.2.723014>. “Critics May Miss The Green Point of the SmartCode.” Planetizen. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://www.planetizen.com/ node/36887>. Davenport May, Dorothy Anderson. 2005. Getting from Sense of Place to Place-based Management: An Investigation of Place Meanings and Perceptions of Landscape Change. Society & Natural Resources 18:625 –641. Ernstson, H., van der Leeuw, S. E., Redman, C. L., Meffert, D. J., Davis, G., Alfsen, C., & Elmqvist, T. (2010). Urban transitions: on urban resilience and human-dominated ecosystems. AMBIO: a journal of the human environment, 39(8), 531-545. Ewing, H. (Director). (2012). Detropia [Documentary]. United States: New Video. Fairfax Renaissance Development Corporation. (n.d.). Fairfax Renaissance Development Corporation. Retrieved November 22, 2012, from http://www.fairfaxrenaissance.org/ “Forests.” : 8. What Are the Economic and Social Benefits of Forests? N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://www.greenfacts. org/en/forests/l-2/8-economic-social-benefits.htm>.
“Cleveland Area History.” Cleveland Area History. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://www.clevelandareahistory.com/>. “Greening The Rubble.” Greening The Rubble. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://greeningtherubble.org.nz/wp/>. Cleveland City Planning Commission. (n.d.). Cleveland City Planning Commission. Retrieved November 22, 2012, from http:// planning.city.cleveland.oh.us/census/factsheets/cpc.html Cleveland could hold the future of the foreclosure crisis: Demolition - The Washington Post. (n.d.). Washington Post: Breaking News, World, US, DC News & Analysis. Retrieved November 16, 2012, from http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/ economy/cleveland-could-hold-the-future-of-the-foreclosure-crisis-demolition/2011/10/09/gIQACK1AgL_gallery.html#photo=20 Cuyahoga Land Bank - Demolition and Vacant Lot Reuse. (n.d.). Cuyahoga Land Bank - Home Page. Retrieved November 17, 2012, from http://www.cuyahogalandbank.org/demolition.php
Großmann, K., Beauregard, R., Dewar, M., & Haase, A. (2012). European and US perspectives on shrinking cities. Urban Research & Practice, 5(3), 360-363. Hayden, D. (1988). Placemaking, preservation and urban history. Journal of Architectural Education, 45-51. “Kinsman Neighborhood in Cleveland, Ohio (OH), 44104, 44105 Detailed Profile.” Kinsman Neighborhood in Cleveland, Ohio (OH), 44104, 44105 Subdivision Profile. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://www.city-data.com/neighborhood/KinsmanCleveland-OH.html>.
107
108
forest city INFILL
kammeron hughes
kammeron hughes
references
Kirk, D. S., & Laub, J. H. (2010). Neighborhood change and crime in the modern metropolis. Crime and Justice, 39(1), 441502.
forest city INFILL references
Ryan, B. D. (2012). Design after decline: how America rebuilds shrinking cities. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Krohe Jr, J. (2011). The Incredible Shrinking City. Planning, 77(9). “RTA History.” N.p., n.d. Web. L.A. Bulldozes Foreclosed Homes To Create More Urban Green Space | Co.Exist: World changing ideas and innovation. (n.d.). Co.Exist: World changing ideas and innovation. Retrieved October 1, 2012, from http://www.fastcoexist.com/1680644/labulldozes-foreclosed-homes-to-create-more-urban-green-space?utm_source=twitter
“The City of Portland, Oregon.” Get Involved. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://www.portlandoregon.gov/parks/ article/424031>.
“Let Your Trees Grow For Profit.” WoodMagazine.com. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://www.woodmagazine.com/materialsguide/lumber/let-your-trees-grow-for-profit/>.
Tortorello, Michael. “IN THE GARDEN; What’s Left Behind.” The New York Times. The New York Times, 04 Aug. 2011. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/04/garden/finding-the-potential-in-vacant-lots-in-the-garden.html?pagewanted=all>.
Martinez Fernandez,C., Audirac, I., Fol, S., & Cunningham Sabot, E . (2012). Shrinking cities: urban challenges of globalization. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research.
Van Buren, Wendi. “Economic Benefits of Urban Forests.” Ohio DNR. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://www.ohiodnr.com/ LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=vTeQHBUa4DQ=>.
MoMA | Foreclosed: Rehousing the American Dream. (n.d.). MoMA | The Museum of Modern Art. Retrieved September 5, 2012, from http://www.moma.org/explore/inside_out/2011/06/09/foreclosed-rehousing-the-american-dream
Weber, C. (2011). The Amazing Shrinking City. E-the Environmental Magazine, 22(2), 12.
“NE Ohio Indicator Data.” N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://neocando.case.edu/neocando/>. “News.” Keep Growing Detroit. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://detroitagriculture.net/>. “Northeast Ohio.” The Plain Dealer. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://blog.cleveland.com/metro/2011/10/regional_sewer_ district_to_spe.html>. “Northeast Ohio.” The Plain Dealer. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://www.cleveland.com/metro/index.ssf/2012/11/sewer_ district_officials_notif.html>. “Northeast Ohio.” The Plain Dealer. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://www.cleveland.com/metro/index.ssf/2013/03/utility_ list_shows_more_than_1.html>. “Office of Sustainability.” City of Cleveland. N.p., n.d. Web. <http://www.city.cleveland.oh.us/CityofCleveland/Home/ Government/CityAgencies/OfficeOfSustainability>. “Reconfiguring the Urban Unit.” KDFProjects. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 May 2013. <http://www.kdf-p.com/urban-design/reconfiguringthe-urban-unit/>. Rego, R. L. (2012). Importing planning ideas, mirroring progress: the hinterland and the metropolis in mid-twentiethcentury Brazil.
Wiechmann, T., & Pallagst, K. M. (2012). Urban shrinkage in Germany and the USA: a comparison of transformation patterns and local strategies. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research. Where is the opportunity in Opportunity Corridor? | GreenCityBlueLake | Sustainability in Northeast Ohio at The Cleveland Museum of Natural History. (n.d.). GreenCityBlueLake | Sustainability in Northeast Ohio at The Cleveland Museum of Natural History. Retrieved November 16, 2012, from http://www.gcbl.org/blog/2009/09/where-is-the-opportunity-in-opportunitycorridor
109