CENTENNIAL PARK VISITOR CENTER NASHVILLE URBAN DESIGN PROGRAM SUMMER 2014 University of Tennessee, Knoxville College of Architecture and Design Nashville Civic Design Center Publication by Paul Bamson and Hayley Mull
CENTENNIAL PARK VISITOR CENTER NASHVILLE URBAN DESIGN PROGRAM SUMMER 2014
01
01
01
01
01
01
CREDITS FACULTY Thomas K. Davis Associate Professor, University of Tennessee Gary Gaston Design Director, NCDC Lecturer, University of Tennessee DESIGN REVIEW CRITICS PRELIMINARY DESIGN REVIEWERS Tara Armistead Principal, Tara Armistead Landscape Architect Keith Covington Principal, Third Coast Design Studio Tim Netsch Assistant Director, Metro Parks and Recreation Wesley Paine Director, The Parthenon Ron Yearwood Urban Designer, NCDC PENULTIMATE DESIGN REVIEWERS John Houghton Senior Planner, Gresham, Smith and Partners David Koellein Agent, Zeitlin and Company Realtors FINAL DESIGN REVIEWERS Eric McGinnis Intern Architect, EOA Architects Tim Netsch Assistant Director, Metro Parks and Recreation Adam Nicholson Designer, Gresham, Smith and Partners Wesley Paine Director, The Parthenon Cyril Stewart Cyril Stewart Architect STUDENTS Paul Bamson Fourth Year Architecture Student Dylan Buc Fifth Year Architecture Student Hayley Mull Fourth Year Architecture Student Josh Parsley Fourth Year Architecture Student Alex Pasley Fourth Year Architecture Student INSTITUTIONAL PARTNERS The University of Tennessee, Knoxville College of Architecture and Design Nashville Civic Design Center (NCDC)
5
TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION 8-13 Nashville Urban Design Program Summer 2014 10-11 Centennial Park Visitor Center Problem Statement 12-13 MASTER PLAN 14-23 Centennial Park Legacy 16-17 Proposed Master Plan 18-19 Surrounding Site Elements 20-21 Proposed Park Circulation and Parking 22-23 PRECEDENTS 24-35 Acropolis Museum 26-27 Brooklyn Botanic Garden Visitor Center 28-29 French Gardens 30-31 Galileo Control Center 32-33 Paley Park 34-35 VISITOR CENTER 36-83 Project Introductions/ Program 38-59 Public Space 60-65 Terrace Space 66-71 Event Space 72-77 Private Space 78-83 APPENDIX 84-91 Bibliography 86-89 Acknowledgments 90-91
7
INTRODUCTION
01
11
NASHVILLE URBAN DESIGN PROGRAM PROGRAM OVERVIEW
During Summer 2014, the University of Tennessee, Knoxville, College of Architecture and Design offered an urban design program based at the Nashville Civic Design Center (www.civicdesigncenter.org), to the synergy and mutual benefit of the College at the Center. This was an extension of the 13-year long partnership between the two entities. The Nashville Urban Design Program utilized Metropolitan Nashville and Middle Tennessee as a laboratory to visit and experience the issues and opportunities confronting the region, including examples of its most interesting historic and contemporary architecture and public spaces.
THE NASHVILLE CIVIC DESIGN CENTER
01
Founded in 2000, the Nashville Civic Design Center is a nonprofit organization whose mission is to elevate the quality of Nashville’s built environment and to promote public participation in the creation of a more beautiful and functional city for all. The NCDC promotes the Ten Principles and related goals of The Plan of Nashville, a vision for growth and development, created and endorsed by citizens of Nashville.
PROGRAM CURRICULUM
Summer Session One was comprised of five architecture students who addressed urban design projects responding to specific Greater Nashville conditions, and explored urban issues in understanding and making the architecture of the city. Their investigations analyzed cultural, physical, and environmental influences and precedents of community on architectural form, space, and structure in the civic realm.
01
Summer Session Two was comprised of two of the five architecture students in directed research. These two students produced a publication documenting the studio’s work during the first session design studio. 02
01
03
13
A VISITOR CENTER FOR CENTENNIAL PARK The problem addressed involved the design, as urban architecture, of a Visitor Center for historic Centennial Park in Nashville’s West End. Centennial Park was the site of the Tennessee Centennial Exposition in 1897, and in 2010 was the subject of a distinguished new master plan by world-class landscape architect Kathryn Gustafson. This master plan is the outcome of numerous public meetings over a two-year period. Students focused on the proposed site for the Visitor Center which is at a highly strategic urban corner of the park. This Visitor Center, while located in the master plan, has not been designed. This studio presented the potential to get in on the ground floor and influence subsequent professional design services on its design and development as an advocacy.
The Master Plan states “the Visitor Center will be a place where park users can go to orient themselves and to find out what is happening in Centennial Park. The building will create another venue for indoor events in addition to the fully booked Parthenon. The light/open structure will house a cafe space with a terrace that expands into the ornamental garden toward the Parthenon, The building will create a lovely vista from the Parthenon and (may) block the current view of the 31st Avenue traffic.” The Master Plan goes on to say “the new Visitor Center will be set on the west axis of the Parthenon near the intersection of Parthenon Avenue and 31st Avenue North. It will be designed to create a new park entry fronting onto a street-level arrival plaza with terraced hillside gardens to the north... and will include a small cafe, event rooms, and outdoor terraces with views eastward to the Parthenon, the park, and the downtown skyline.”
As a studio of five students, they periodically presented the five projects to a number of the most distinguished design and development professionals in the city, including many of University of Tennessee alumni, as well as key city officials.
Following a site visit, the students engaged in graphic site analysis, and a more elaborated program description for each project, after meeting with officials from the Parks and Recreation Department and its Parthenon staff. 02
04.1
MASTER PLAN
CENTENNIAL PARK LEGACY “Centennial Park holds a special place in the history of Nashville and in the hearts of our citizens. The park was first created to hold the Centennial Exposition of 1897, a six-month event that brought nearly 2 million visitors to Nashville at a time when the city’s population was barely 100,000. It was the start of not only Nashville’s municipal park system, but public park systems across the state. Since then, Centennial Park has been a place where the people of our city gather and celebrate. The events held here throughout the years - large and small - have reflected the changing culture and values of our city. The Centennial Park Master Plan is the result of two years of effort by the Centennial Park Master Plan Committee. This dedicated group of volunteers spent long hours deliberating and focusing their efforts so that we would have a distinctive plan that honors the history of the park and also accommodates modern uses that will stand the test of time. The committee recruited world renowned landscape architects Gustafson Guthrie Nichol, and worked closely with Design Partner Kathryn Gustafson and her team to articulate a shared vision. They sought input from
the community through a series of well-attended public sessions, and they made sure the vision and plan created reflected the users’ desires. Centennial Park is already one of our busiest and most frequented parks in Nashville. This master plan looks into the future and lays out a blueprint for the park to become a showpiece for the city and our region. Also it envisions careful change that maintains the essential character that our citizens love while making it an even more vibrant and compelling park and destination for visitors. Centennial Park has been an essential part of the city’s fabric for more than a century. It is my hope that this master plan will lay the course for Centennial Park to remain the crown jewel of our city’s park system for the next century and beyond. It will continue to be a place for fun, a place for music, a place for art, and a place for the community to gather. Thank you to all of you that have been part of this process.” 04.2 Mayor Karl Dean
04.3
04.3
04.3
17
04.4
04.4
03.3
04.4
04.4
04.3
04.3
PROPOSED MASTER PLAN 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25 26.
Natchez Trace Monument Cockrill Spring West Musicians Corner Lake Katherine East Musicians Corner Gold Star Monument Shell Spring Gunboat TN Monument Bridge at Lick Branch Sewer Great Lawn Mowable Meadow Events Pavilion + Restrooms Robertson Monument TN Centennial Expo. Marker Lake Watauga Bridge Lake Watauga East Playground Interactive Water Feature CP Cafe East + Restrooms Sculpture + Installation Garden Art Center + Pool Area Garden North East Picnic Area Frist Memorial Garden Locomotive 576+N.C.& SL Railway Monument Rain Gardens Woman’s Monument
27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51.
Confederate Private Monument Lily Lake Concrete Bridge Cherry Blossom Walk Events Terrace Native Woodland Large Dog Park Small Dog Park Service Area + Shared Parking Flag Pole Hill Water Feature + Path Terrace Ramps + Gardens Winter Garden + Visitors Center Formal Gardens + Arrival Plaza Reflecting Pool Parthenon Marker Parthenon Victims of Violence, Children’s Memorial Garden Thomas Monument Rose Arbor + Gardens Centennial Park Arts + Activities Center Demonstration / Food Garden West Playground Cafe West + Restrooms Picnic Pavilion Parking Lots
04.5
19
SURROUNDING SITE ELEMENTS
Demonstration Garden
04.6
04.6
04.6
04.6
04.7
04.7
Great Lawn
Rose Arbor + Garden
21
Winter Garden + Entry Plaza Gardens
05
04.7
04.8
04.8
06
04.8
Reflecting Pool
Flag Pole Hill Grottos + Lower Terrace Pools
PROPOSED PARK CIRCULATION AND PARKING All Access Drive/ Loop/ Drop Off Occasional Access Drive
open - weekdays closed - events + weekends
Events + Emergency Drive Drop-Off Street Parking All Use Parking Lots Shared Use Parking Lots
evenings/ weekends/ events
Event Parking Vehicular Circulation (20’ Wide) Pedestrian Traffic Bicycles Allowed Park Maintenance VIP + ADA Drop Off Emergency Vehicles Delivery Trucks
Selected Vehicle Access
closed evenings/ weekends/ events
Major Pedestrian Circulation Pedestrian Traffic Jogging Loop - 1 mile Bicycle Allowed Park Maintenance
04.9
Minor Pedestrian Circulation Pedestrian Path Maintenance Path Bicycles Prohibited
Vehicle Entries Pedestrian Entries
Existing Conditions
04.9
04.10
23
04.10
PRECEDENTS
ACROPOLIS MUSEUM Athens, Greece 2009 Bernard Tschumi Architects The Acropolis Museum is located in Makryianni, the historic district. Completed in 2009, it sits southeast of the Parthenon just 1,000 feet. The Museum has 90,000 square feet of space for exhibitions and amenities for visitors. The entry to the museum is on the pedestrian street, Dionysios Areopagitou. There is a 360-degree view of Athens and the Acropolis on the top level gallery. “The Acropolis Museum tells the story of life on the Athenian Acropolis and its surroundings by uniting collections formerly dispersed in multiple institutions, including the small Acropolis Museum built in the 19th century.� 58
07
08
Points of Inspiration
1. Its Massing and Form 2. Exposure of Structure 3. Facade design 4. Directions of Views 5. Respect for Acropolis and Sensitivity to surrounding site
19
09
20
10
11
27
12
13
14
15
16, 17
18
BROOKLYN BOTANIC GARDEN VISITOR CENTER
Brooklyn, New York 2012 WEISS / MANFREDI The Visitor Center, designed by New York City’s WEISS / MANFREDI for the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, opened May 16 of 2012. It lies on Washington Avenue on the corner of the garden on the northeast side. “The building is a fitting addition to the garden as Brooklyn Botanic Garden advances in its second century; It is a good precedent for building sustainably and for merging building and landscape.” 58
21
Points of Inspiration
1. Green roof blurs building and landscape 2. Glass facades open up building 3. Skylight pulls light into public spaces 4. Being set back from street draws people in 5. Building is integrated with site
22
23
24
25
29
26
27
28
29
30
FRENCH GARDENS France 16th Century French gardens are often thought of as the traditional style of ‘formal bedding schemes’ in places like Chateau de Hautefort and Versailles. Though, there are much smaller types which consist of planting and bedding schemes that are more relaxed, these smaller scales are becoming much more popular. French gardens range from very hot and dry to cool and wet climates choosing plants based on what is adaptable. 59
31
32
33
34
35
36
Points of Inspiration
1. Brings order and organization to nature 2. Spaces for relaxation and reflection 3. Diversity of plants, trees, and bedding 4. Variety of meanings and purposes 5. Creats a sense of place
31
GALILEO CONTROL CENTER Oberpfaffenhofen, Germany 2008 Schultes Frank Architekten This building exists as two buildings built on top of one another rather than a single form. The hierarchy of these buildings is based off of the security system. The bottom building occupies control rooms, laboratories, computer racks, etc. resting below ground. The main level, however, houses an auditorium, cafe, offices, visitors galleries, etc. behind the large curving facade. Everything is placed and built according to sheltering against interference. The Control Center takes on a role past its program “with spacial suggestions of Galilean contradiction, a silent move, heavy in material, displaying the lightness of stone, cast stone, glowing in the light.� 60
37
Points of Inspiration
1. Correlation/ rhythm of solid and void 2. Correlation of heavy and light material 3. Complimenting curvature of the facade 4. Floor- ceiling glass creating hierarchy of spaces 5. Relationship of the ground and facade patterns 38
40
39
NASHVILLE PUBLIC SQUARE Nashville, TN 2003 Tuck Hinton Architects “A central, oval-shaped lawn acts as a flexible space suitable for large gatherings. Participatory fountains, river overlooks, and memorials energize the surrounding streetspace, knitting the square into the larger urban context.” Below this lies an underground parking garage holding 1,200 parking spots for employees and visitors of the courthouse. This space acts as a place for activity to happen in every season and “celebrates the courthouse by providing a tree-lined frame, punctuated by civic monuments and gateways.” 61
41
Points of Inspiration
1. Towers frame gateway entry 2. Ground covering creates spacial hierarchy 3. Year round space open to the public 4. Parking moved to allow public dominance 5. Flexible space for any number of occupants
42
43
33
45
44
46
47
48
PALEY PARK
New York City, NY 1967 Zion and Breen Associates “Paley Park is often cited as one of the finest urban spaces in the United States.� This 4,200 square feet pocket park on East 53rd Street allows the busy streets of Midtown Manhattan to fade away with the sound of a waterfall spanning the entire back wall. The other three walls are ivy-covered with airy honey locust trees gridded in the center and light movable furniture creating an urban oasis. Zion & Breen, the landscape architects, finished the pocket park in 1967 opening on May 23rd of that year. 58
49
50
51
52
53
54
Points of Inspiration
1. Slightly raised to create private space 2. Honey locusts provide excellent shading 3. Integrated nature with ivy- covered walls 4. Glowing water fall for soothing sound 5. Social atmosphere with nearby amenities
55
56
35
CENTENNIAL PARK VISITOR CENTER
PROJECT INTRODUCTIONS These five projects aim to provide a hub of public and private spaces for learning about the Parthenon and Centennial Park. Each project tackles these design problems differently and takes a unique approach to the program organization. The program used by the students was implemented as a reference based off of information gathered from Metro Parks and Recreactions Assistant Director, Tim Netsch, and the Director of the Parthenon, Wesley Paine. Each student added program elements and/or excluded them based off of individual goals and project intent. In This Section Visitor Center Program Student Biographies Project Summaries Early Process Drawings Final Plan Drawings
39
VISITOR CENTER PROGRAM PUBLIC
Ticketing / Information / Reception 840 net square feet Museum Store Orientation / Interpretation Space Cafe 1200 Multipurpose Meeting Space 1200
EVENT
Ballroom (300-500 people) 7500
TERRACE(S)
Ballroom expansion area Additional terrace open to public at all times Cafe seating Lounge seating / general public plaza Gather space for tours
PRIVATE
Conference Room (8 people) 240 Staff Restrooms 300 Break Room 150 Parks Staff 150 Private (1) 800 Open (8) Conservancy Staff Private (1) 150 Open (8) 800
SUPPORT
Storage (throughout) Public Restrooms (accessible after hours) Public Restrooms interior to building Custodial closets Mechanical Space Electrical Elevator(s) / Equipment
TOTAL NET SQUARE FEET TOTAL GROSS SQUARE FEET
400 600
15,000 20,000
PROCESS
9 SQUARE
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PARK ZONE GARDEN ZONE
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PUBLIC ZONE
RODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRIVATE ZONE
EVENT ZONE PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
9 SQUARE GRID
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
Studying Centennial Park, I noticed that the park has three major zones; a park zone, a lake zone, and a garden zone. These three zones happen to meet at the site location and are defined by those components. The main concept is to reflect the concept of three major zones in the design of the building. The three zones being a public zone, a private zone, and an event zone. Next, I studied the master plan and found that the gardens surrounding the site have a repetition which was mainly A-B-A-B. Using the regulating lines pulled from the repetition of the gardens, a 9 Square Grid was created defining the program organization of the building. The 9 square grid consists of 40’ and 10’ zones. The 40’ zones consist of program spaces and the 10’ zones consist of circulation, storage, and services spaces like restrooms and mechanical/ electrical rooms.
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
Project Summary
LAKE ZONE
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
Paul Bamson was born in Nigeria, but has lived in Nashville for most of his life. He attended Montgomery Bell Academy before attending the University of Tennessee for Architecture. Math and art have always been a passion for him and architecture combines both. He hopes to someday start his own firm and better lives through design.
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
Paul Bamson Fourth Year Architecture Student University of Tennessee, Knoxville College of Architecture and Design
41
9 SQUARE
ROOF PLAN
N
0
20
40
80
LEVEL 3 PLAN
43
LEVEL 2 PLAN
LEVEL 1 PLAN
THE AGORA Dylan Buc Fifth Year Architecture Student University of Tennessee, Knoxville College of Architecture and Design Dylan Buc is a Nashville native and attended Hume-Fogg Academic High School in downtown Nashville. He is in his last semester before earning his Bachelor’s Degree in Architecture, and wishes to begin his professional career in the city that has been home to his family for four generations.
Project Summary
During the preliminary analysis of Centennial Park, I took notice of the many different elements and amenities that already existed-- many of which I did not know were present. This experience is similar to many who visit the park. One does not know what is actually in the park because it is not advertised well, nor are they aware of its significance in the history of Nashville. Thus, I sought to design a visitor center that not only addresses the Parthenon, but celebrates Centennial Park as a whole. The design would incorporate a new way-finding system that promotes walkability, while actively engaging the visitor through education about the unique elements of Centennial Park.
PROCESS
45
THE AGORA ROOF PLAN
N
0
20
40
80
AXONOMETRIC
47
LEVEL 2 PLAN
LEVEL 1 PLAN
A GROWING VIEW Hayley Mull Fourth Year Architecture Student University of Tennessee, Knoxville College of Architecture and Design Hayley Mull calls the Nashville area home, growing up just south in Franklin, Tennessee. Graduating from Independence High School, she was heavily involved in community service and missionary organizations. Currently studying architecture at the University of Tennessee, she hopes to continue missionary work with her degree.
PROJECT SUMMARY
The Visitor Center rests in the heart of the formal gardens urging a dialogue with Centennial Park as a whole, while also being straight on axis with the Parthenon’s west facade. With its concave facade, the Visitor Center does not compete with the Parthenon’s, but rather embraces it. Using regulating lines from the surrounding formal gardens as well as vegetation itself, it creates a blur between the interiors and exteriors. This is displayed mainly with an open air atrium inhabiting 1/4 of the building’s footprint, living walls, and an ivy- covered pergola spanning the roof. A viewing terrace on grade with 31st Avenue celebrates the views for the park as a whole and tucks away the building, yet the strong use of materiality and solid/ void lets it stand out. Complimenting the strong presence of the Parthenon and making a statement within its site allows the Visitor Center to nestle itself gracefully into Centennial Park.
PROCESS
49
A GROWING VIEW
AXONOMETRIC
N
0
20
40
80
51
LEVEL 2 PLAN
LEVEL 1 PLAN
THE BRIDGE TO CENTENNIAL Joshua Parsley Fourth Year Architecture Student University of Tennessee, Knoxville College of Architecture and Design A native of Tennessee, Joshua Parsley attended Ravenwood High School as an active designer and athlete on the basketball team. Currently pursuing a double major in architecture and bio chemistry, he hopes to combine a gifted talent of design with a passion for the plant sciences.
Project Summary
When creating a space intended for visitors to populate, direction and insight are paramount in its design. To successfully integrate these elements, the concept of exposure must be considered. The Visitor Center at Centennial Park focuses on this idea of exposure by acknowledging visitor intentions while discretely informing them of details and relative context. As the space is inhabited, qualities of the park such as views from the site and information on other events and properties of Centennial are exposed to the visitor. This may happen at the point of entry where a grand perspective of the Parthenon is framed by two towering volumes or on the bridge in which adjoins the forms, giving views to nearly the entire park. Exposing this vision to visitors not only educates their understanding and properties of the park, but it orientates them in relation to their position. Exposure is critical in maintaining a successful visitor center, without it, Centennial Park risks a complete disregard to its beauty and qualities it possess.
PROCESS
53
THE BRIDGE TO CENTENNIAL
ROOF PLAN
N
0
20
40
80
LEVEL 3 PLAN
55
LEVEL 2 PLAN
LEVEL 1 PLAN
THE JEWEL IN THE CITY Alex Pasley Fourth Year Architecture Student University of Tennessee, Knoxville College of Architecture and Design Alex Pasley was born in Franklin, Tennessee, and graduated from Page High School before attending the University of Tennessee. His hobbies and strengths like drawing, art, math, and community work helped pick his career path and combined his passionate goals to pursue architecture as his major.
PROJECT SUMMARY
The Visitor Center was designed to create a new parkway entrance on a street level plaza “The Jewel In The City”. The design is based architecturally off of the Parthenon’s form, scale, proportions, and elegance. I started by looking at the master plan and began pulling regulating lines from the public and rose gardens to create zones on the terrace and lower levels. The intersecting zones help create two glass boxes on the terrace level. The boxes disappear during the day and are lanterns at night that frame the Parthenon from a distance. The terrace level is an active space during the day and night for special events and a space for one to see Nashville in a new way. The lower level is based around the ballroom and is split into three zones. The first zone is the private and public offices and lecture hall. The second zone is the lobby space and ballroom which is pulled out of the ground. The third zone is the restrooms and the circulation zone. The ballroom is meant to mirror the Parthenon giving a 180 degree view of Centennial Park.
PROCESS
57
THE JEWEL IN THE CITY
AXONOMETRIC
N
0
20
40
80
59
LEVEL 2 PLAN
LEVEL 1 PLAN
PUBLIC SPACE Great public spaces enhance a visitor’s experience tremendously. The public spaces addressed in the Visitor Center include a cafe, gallery, multipurpose meeting room, orientation/ film room, museum store, reception area, and ticketing area. In This Section Plans and Axons for orientation Perspectives showing Public Space Sections showing Public Space
61
9 SQUARE LEFT IMAGE
Roof Plan
BELOW IMAGE
View from Formal Gardens into Courtyard
The two main public spaces are the outdoor terrace, where the exterior seating for the cafe is located, and the courtyard, which is an extension of the ballroom and event spaces.
THE AGORA LEFT IMAGE
Axonometric
BELOW IMAGE
Longitudinal Section to Parthenon
There are three levels of public space shown in the section cut through the double height ballroom on the ground floor and viewing terrace above on grade with 31st Avenue.
A GROWING VIEW
ABOVE IMAGE Level 2 Plan UPPER RIGHT IMAGE Aerial perspective of sunken outdoor atrium LOWER RIGHT IMAGE View from entry of mezzanine Large public areas face the gardens except the sunken atrium on the back side to allow light in on all sides.
63
THE BRIDGE TO CENTENNIAL
ABOVE IMAGE Level 2 Plan UPPER RIGHT IMAGE Night view of towers LOWER RIGHT IMAGE View of interior ballroom Exterior spaces dominate this design during all times of the day, but large interior spaces make their mark as well with its circulation through the Visitor Center.
65
THE JEWEL IN THE CITY LEFT IMAGE
Level 2 Plan
BELOW IMAGE
Longitudinal section through multipurpose and office space
Public terrace on-grade with 31st Avenue stays open during the day, whereas the interior large ballroom makes a statement with its plunge out into the formal gardens.
TERRACE SPACE In the master plan by Gustafson Guthrie Nichol, a terrace space was mentioned as a place for people to gather and have a great view of the Parthenon and Centennial Park. It is also a space for people to eat and hold outdoor events with a removable tent. In This Section Plans and Axons for orientation Perspectives showing Terrace Space Sections showing Terrace Space Elevations showing Terrace Space
67
9 SQUARE LEFT IMAGE
Axonometric
BELOW IMAGE
View of terrace facing the Parthenon
The exterior seating for the cafe is shaded by a canopy with vines growing along it to filter light. The terrace is also a space where large tour groups can be dropped off by car and bus.
THE AGORA LEFT IMAGE
Level 2 Plan
BELOW IMAGE
Transverse section cutting through ballroom and upper terrace
The on-grade terrace spans the roof of the building and shows a removable tent for outdoor events on this level.
69
A GROWING VIEW LEFT IMAGE
Axonometric
BELOW IMAGE
From the Parthenon
The terrace level reflects the spaces in the floors below including the ballroom, the staircases, and even the atrium with a wooden pergola spanning the 200 feet.
THE BRIDGE TO CENTENNIAL
ABOVE IMAGE Roof Plan UPPER RIGHT IMAGE View of Lookout on axis with Parthenon LOWER RIGHT IMAGE Aerial perspective of courtyards and gardens to the Parthenon The terrace spaces exist on different levels with one spanning between the two circulation towers and others gradually making their way down the sloping site.
71
THE JEWEL IN THE CITY LEFT IMAGE
Axonometric
BELOW IMAGE
Elevation from 31st Avenue
This area is elevated above the ground enough to define the space as a terrace and sits between the only two structures on the roof level.
EVENT SPACE The Ballroom is a major part of all of the projects. It is the largest of the program elements and is a great space for parties, dinners, weddings, and conventions. Some spaces can be split in two for multiple events to take place. All projects have a great view of the Parthenon and Centennial Park as a whole. In This Section Plans and Axons for orientation Perspectives showing Event Space Sections showing Event Space Elevations showing Event Space
73
9 SQUARE LEFT IMAGE
Level 1 Plan
MIDDLE IMAGE Transverse section through ballroom BOTTOM IMAGE View from Ballroom towards the Parthenon and formal gardens Level 1 is devoted to the ballroom and event spaces. The ballroom is on the north side of the building directly under the outdoor terrace. The event rooms are on the east side of the building and can be split into two spaces for additional events. The gallery is a mezzanine that wraps around the ballroom.
THE AGORA LEFT IMAGE
Level 1 Plan
BELOW IMAGE
View from ballroom towards the Parthenon and formal gardens
The ballroom exposes the truss system above as well as shows large views of the formal gardens beyond. It is also wrapped by a mezzanine level.
75
A GROWING VIEW LEFT IMAGE
Level 1 Plan
MIDDLE IMAGE Elevation from formal gardens BOTTOM IMAGE Night view from 31st Avenue The interior event space is double height with all other spaces wrapped around it. The exterior event space is reflected directly above it on the terrace level where a removable tent rests.
THE BRIDGE TO CENTENNIAL LEFT IMAGE
Level 1 Plan
BELOW IMAGE
View from lowest courtyard towards Parthenon and formal gardens
The lowest courtyard is directly outside of the interior ballroom allowing events to spill out into this space when the removable tent is set up.
77
THE JEWEL IN THE CITY LEFT IMAGE
Level 1 Plan
MIDDLE IMAGE Longitudinal night section showing jutted out ballroom BOTTOM IMAGE View from interior ballroom towards Pathenon and formal gardens The ballroom is the only space punching into the formal gardens and is glass enclosed on three of its sides.
PRIVATE SPACE The private spaces in most schemes still allow views to the outside without compromising the privacy of offices for the Visitor Center. Offices may be split between the Metro Parks Staff and Conservancy Staff. There are 16 open cubicals and 2 director offices with private restrooms, conference rooms, and break rooms. In This Section Plans for Orientation Sections Showing Private Space Elevation Showing Private Space
79
9 SQUARE LEFT IMAGE
Level 2 Plan
BELOW IMAGE
Longitudinal section through core
Level 2 holds the offices for the staff. It allows for great views of the park as well as views from the conference room and break room. Private restrooms are also available for the staff.
THE AGORA LEFT IMAGE
Level 1 Plan
BELOW IMAGE
Northeast elevation from the gardens
The private spaces are on the south side of the building on Level 1 where sunlight can still reach offices but do not take away from the more dominant public aspects of the building.
81
A GROWING VIEW LEFT IMAGE
Level 1 Plan
MIDDLE IMAGE Longitudinal section through atrium and office space BOTTOM IMAGE Transverse section through office space and ballroom The private spaces wrap around the back of the ballroom on level 1 giving offices, conference rooms, and break rooms natural light through the sunken atrium space.
THE BRIDGE TO CENTENNIAL LEFT IMAGE
Level 1 Plan
BELOW IMAGE
Transverse section through gallery and private space
Behind the larger areas like the gallery and ballroom are the private spaces such as restrooms, mechanical, and storage tucked along each side.
83
THE JEWEL IN THE CITY LEFT IMAGE
Level 1 Plan
BELOW IMAGE
Transverse section through office spaces
The office spaces flank the ballroom on either side. This placement allows them to have the best views as well as the most sunlight, creating the full facade facing the gardens.
APPENDIX
BIBLIOGRAPHY Cover Photo Gustafson Guthrie Nichol. Centennial Park Master Plan. December 2010. http://www.nashville.gov/Parks-and-Recreation/Planning-and-Development/Park-Plans-and-Projects/Centennial-Park.aspx Introduction Photo
Photo courtesy of Paul Bamson
Master Plan Photo Gustafson Guthrie Nichol. Centennial Park Master Plan. December 2010. http://www.nashville.gov/Parks-and-Recreation/Planning-and-Development/Park-Plans-and-Projects/Centennial-Park.aspx
Precedent Photos
Refer to 07, 28, 33, 40, 43, 50 below
01
Photo courtesy of Paul Bamson
02
Courtesy of TK Davis
03
Photo courtesy of Dylan Buc
04 Gustafson Guthrie Nichol. Centennial Park Master Plan. December 2010. http://www.nashville.gov/Parks-and-Recreation/Planning-and-Development/Park-Plans-and-Projects/Centennial-Park.aspx
04.1 04.2 04.3 04.4 04.5 04.6 04.7 04.8 04.9 04.10
page 20 page 1 page 8 page 9 page 19 page 36 page 37 page 47 page 59 page 57
05 Unknown. Geograph - Photograph Every Grid Square. N.d. Tollcross Park. Web. http://s0.geograph.org.uk/photos/94/62/946233_04b18475.jpg 06 Unknown. Tivoli’s Riches: Villa D’Este. N.d. Sue Dyer. Web. http://susankdyer.com/2012/05/20/tivolis-riches-villa-deste/ 07 Courtsey of Bernard Tschumi Architects. n.d. ArchDaily. Web. http://ad009cdnb.archdaily.net/wp-content/uploads/2010/05/1274907938-cr3849-090-528x395.jpg 08 Courtesy of Bernard Tschumi Architects. n.d. ArchDaily. Web. http://www.archdaily.com/61898/new-acropolis-museum-bernard-tschumi-architects/cr3849-013/ 09 Courtesy of Bernard Tschumi Architects. n.d. ArchDaily. Web. http://image.architonic.com/imgArc/project-1/4/5204897/Bernard-Tschumi-Architects-New-Acropolis-Museum-08.jpg 10 Courtesy of Bernard Tschumi Architects. n.d. ArchDaily. Web. http://ad009cdnb.archdaily.net/wp-content/uploads/2010/05/1274907890-2009m26470-327x500.jpg
87 11 Richters, Christian. n.d. Daily Tonic. Web. http://www.dailytonic.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/Bernard-Tschumi-Architects-New-Acropolis-Museum-02.jpg 12 Courtesy of Bernard Tschumi Architects. n.d. ArchDaily. Web. http://www.archdaily.com/61898/new-acropolis-museum-bernard-tschumi-architects/cr3849-003/ 13 Courtesy of Bernard Tschumi Architects. n.d. ArchDaily. Web. http://www.archdaily.com/61898/new-acropolis-museum-bernard-tschumi-architects/p1090816e/ 14 Courtesy of Bernard Tschumi Architects. n.d. ArchDaily. Web. http://www.archdaily.com/61898/new-acropolis-museum-bernard-tschumi-architects/cr3849-171/ 15 Courtesy of Bernard Tschumi Architects. n.d. ArchDaily. Web. http://www.archdaily.com/61898/new-acropolis-museum-bernard-tschumi-architects/new-acropolis-museum-2/ 16
Courtesy of Bernard Tschumi Architects. n.d. ArchDaily. Web. http://www.archdaily.com/61898/new-acropolis-museum-bernard-tschumi-architects/first-floor-plan-94/
17
Courtesy of Bernard Tschumi Architects. n.d. ArchDaily. Web. http://www.archdaily.com/61898/new-acropolis-museum-bernard-tschumi-architects/third-floor-plan-40/
18 Courtesy of Bernard Tschumi Architects. n.d. ArchDaily. Web. http://www.archdaily.com/61898/new-acropolis-museum-bernard-tschumi-architects/section-166/ 19 Courtesy of Bernard Tschumi Architects. n.d. ArchDaily. Web. http://www.archdaily.com/61898/new-acropolis-museum-bernard-tschumi-architects/sketch-02-11/ 20 Courtesy of Bernard Tschumi Architects. n.d. ArchDaily. Web. http://www.archdaily.com/61898/new-acropolis-museum-bernard-tschumi-architects/site-plan-163/ 21 Unknown. n.d. ArchDaily. Site Plan. Web. http://www.archdaily.com/445453/brooklyn-botanic-garden-visitor-center-weiss-manfredi/527846a9e8e44e1d1c000053_brooklyn-botanic-garden-visi tor-center-weiss-manfredi_site_plan-png/ 22 Hill, John. n.d. A Weekly Dose of Architecture. Web. http://archidose.org/wp/2012/05/29/brooklyn-botanic-garden-visitor-center/ 23 Unknown. n.d. Brooklyn Based. “Architecture and Ecology Intertwine at New BBG Visitor Center�. Web. http://brooklynbased.com/blog/2012/06/27/architecture-and-ecology-intertwine-at-new-bbg-visitor-center/ 24 Hill, John. n.d. A Weekly Dose of Architecture. Web. http://archidose.org/wp/2012/05/29/brooklyn-botanic-garden-visitor-center/ 25 Booher, Aaron. n.d. ArchDaily. Brooklyn Botanic Garden Visitor Center. Web. http://www.archdaily.com/445453/brooklyn-botanic-garden-visitor-center-weiss-manfredi/ 26 Hill, John. n.d. A Weekly Dose of Architecture. Web. http://archidose.org/wp/2012/05/29/brooklyn-botanic-garden-visitor-center/
BIBLIOGRAPHY 27 Hill, John. n.d. A Weekly Dose of Architecture. Web. http://archidose.org/wp/2012/05/29/brooklyn-botanic-garden-visitor-center/ 28 Hill, John. n.d. A Weekly Dose of Architecture. Web. http://archidose.org/wp/2012/05/29/brooklyn-botanic-garden-visitor-center/ 29 Vecerka, Albert. n.d. Esto. Web. http://news.esto.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/2012AV24.681.jpg 30 Hill, John. n.d. A Weekly Dose of Architecture. Web. http://archidose.org/wp/2012/05/29/brooklyn-botanic-garden-visitor-center/ 31 Unknown. French Gardens. n.d. “Chateau de Chenonceau Gardens.” Web. http://www.french-gardens.com/gardens/chenonceau.php 32 Unknown. French Garden Design. n.d. French Garden Design. Web. http://www.french-gardens.com/design/frenchgardendesign.php 33 Unknown. n.d. French Gardens. Web http://www.french-gardens.com/gardens/gardenscentral.php 34 Unknown. n.d. World News Mania. “The King’s Home: Versailles.” Web. http://www.worldnewsmania.com/the-kings-home-versailles/ 35 Unknown. 21 February 2013. n.d. Smart Home Architecture. Web. http://smarthomearchitecture.us/2013/second-session-from-best-garden-design-ideas-this-year/attachment/10033 36 Unknown. n.d. France This Way. Angers. Web. http://www.francethisway.com/places/angers.php 37 Courtesy of Schultes Frank Architekten. n.d. Galileo Control Center. Web. http://www.schultesfrankarchitekten.de/ 38 Courtesy of Schultes Frank Architekten. n.d. Galileo Control Center. Web. http://www.schultesfrankarchitekten.de/ 39 Courtesy of Schultes Frank Architekten. n.d. Galileo Control Center. Web. http://www.schultesfrankarchitekten.de/ 40 Courtesy of Schultes Frank Architekten. n.d. Galileo Control Center. Web. http://www.schultesfrankarchitekten.de/ 41 Unknown. Nashville Public Square. N.d. Tuck Hinton Architects Nashville Public Square. Web. http://tuck-hinton.com/portfolio/nashville-public-square-featured/ 42 Unknown. Nashville Public Square. N.d. Nashville, TN. Wallace Roberts and Todd. Web. http://www.wrtdesign.com/projects/detail/nashville-public-square/84 43 Unknown. Nashville Public Square. N.d. Tuck Hinton Architects Nashville Public Square. Web. http://tuck-hinton.com/portfolio/nashville-public-square-featured/
89 44 Unknown. Nashville Public Square. N.d. Tuck Hinton Architects Nashville Public Square. Web. http://tuck-hinton.com/portfolio/nashville-public-square-featured/ 45 Unknown. Nashville Public Square. N.d. Nashville, TN. Wallace Roberts and Todd. Web. http://www.wrtdesign.com/projects/detail/nashville-public-square/84 46 Unknown. Nashville Public Square. N.d. Tuck Hinton Architects Nashville Public Square. Web. http://tuck-hinton.com/portfolio/nashville-public-square-featured/ 47 Unknown. Nashville Public Square. N.d. Tuck Hinton Architects Nashville Public Square. Web. http://tuck-hinton.com/portfolio/nashville-public-square-featured/ 48 Unknown. Nashville Public Square. N.d. Tuck Hinton Architects Nashville Public Square. Web. http://tuck-hinton.com/portfolio/nashville-public-square-featured/ 49 Gartner, Susan. Paley Park. Oil on Canvas. 2010. Web. http://www.susangartner.com/paley-park/ 50
Bleue, Chimay. Paley Park. 10 August 2012. flickr. Web. 6 July 2014. https://www.flickr.com/photos/88017382@N00/7799724746/
51
Hall, Jacob. paley park no. 1. 15 February 2008. flickr. Web. 28 July 2014. https://www.flickr.com/photos/jakehall/2276996215/
52 Unknown. “Paley Park.” Paley Park. n.p., n.d. Web. <http://www.pps.org/great_public_spaces/one?public_place_id=69> 53 Courtesy of Cornell University. n.d. Paley Park. New York City. Web. https://courses.cit.cornell.edu/lanar5240/Paley1.jpg 54 Paley Park in NYC. 2013. Studio G Architects. By Unknown. Web. <http://blogstudiog.com/2013/10/01/pocket-parks-make-their-mark/> 55 Unknown. 22 January 2012. Meetatmantua. Web. http://meetatmantua.blogspot.com/2012/01/peaks-valleys-abruzzo-architects.html 56
Unknown. n.d. StudyBlue. Web. http://classconnection.s3.amazonaws.com/371/flashcards/812371/jpg/paley_park1321226311944.jpg
57
Photo courtesy of Ron Yearwood
58
Quotes and information provided by www.archdaily.com
59
Quotes and information provided by www.french-gardens.com
60
Quotes and information provided by www.schultesfrankarchitekten.com
61
Quotes and information provided by www.tuck-hinton.com
57
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS SPECIAL THANKS TO Thomas K Davis
Associate Professor, University of Tennessee
Gary Gaston Design Director, Nashville Civic Design Center Lecturer, University of Tennessee Julia Landstreet
Executive Director, Nashville Civic Design Center
Tim Netsch
Assistant Director, Metro Parks and Recreation
Wesley Paine
Director, The Parthenon
Ron Yearwood
Urban Designer, Nashville Civic Design Center
Publication formatted by Paul Bamson and Hayley Mull
91
V